Beware of Munich

Historical analogies can lead decision-makers dangerously astray. Should a crisis break out with China, the US should exercise great caution in seeking guidance from them, especially the 1938 Munich meeting between Hitler and Chamberlain.

If a major crisis in the South China Sea or Taiwan Strait punctuates the US-China competition, decision-makers should exercise great caution in relying on historical analogies to “evaluate” the stakes, says the writer. PHOTO: REUTERS
New: Gift this subscriber-only story to your friends and family

How do wars start? Sometimes, it's because leaders apply the wrong lessons of history.

Then US President Lyndon Johnson, for example, scribbled to himself while deliberating whether to intervene massively in Vietnam: "To give in = another Munich. If not here - then Thailand." Mr Johnson's old friend, Senator Mike Mansfield, repeatedly warned him that Vietnam was not "another Munich", but his warnings fell on deaf ears. The net result was a war lost, and over 50,000 American soldiers and millions of Vietnamese killed.

Already a subscriber? 

Read the full story and more at $9.90/month

Get exclusive reports and insights with more than 500 subscriber-only articles every month

Unlock these benefits

  • All subscriber-only content on ST app and

  • Easy access any time via ST app on 1 mobile device

  • E-paper with 2-week archive so you won't miss out on content that matters to you

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.