Indonesia gains heft in Islamic banking with 3-way merger

By merging syariah units of three lenders, country aims to capture bigger slice of market

A Bank Negara Indonesia (BNI) teller serving a customer in Banda Aceh in May. Last Tuesday, the Indonesian government announced that it would merge the syariah units of three state-owned lenders, including BNI, to form the country’s seventh-largest
A Bank Negara Indonesia (BNI) teller serving a customer in Banda Aceh in May. Last Tuesday, the Indonesian government announced that it would merge the syariah units of three state-owned lenders, including BNI, to form the country’s seventh-largest bank. The new bank will be better placed to raise funds at more competitive rates, S&P said in an analyst note last Thursday.PHOTO: EPA-EFE

In Indonesia, being seen as halal is serious business.

Starbucks and KFC show off their halal certification from the country’s top clerical body even though the franchises are rarely associated with booze or bacon.

But when it comes to banking, Indonesian households and businesses are less picky.

Less than 10 per cent of the country’s banking assets – business loans, mortgages and other lending – are held by the country’s syariah banks, according to Indonesia’s Financial Services Authority (OJK).

As a result, the country’s lenders are minnows in the syariah banking world, holding just 2 per cent of an estimated US$1.6 trillion (S$2.2 trillion) in Islamic banking assets including sukuk – Islamic-compliant bonds.

That is well behind Malaysia, which holds more than 11 per cent, according to data from the Islamic Financial Services Board (IFSB), the multilateral organisation overseeing syariah banking.

That may be changing, as Indonesia’s syariah banks are on a relative tear during the coronavirus pandemic. OJK data shows lending up by more than 20 per cent so far this year as their conventional cousins, which tend to offer bigger loans for longer periods, step back.

Syariah banks get around charging interest on loans through profit sharing arrangements or acting as an intermediary, buying an asset like a car on behalf of the client with an agreed repayment schedule.

Last Tuesday, the Indonesian government announced that it would merge the syariah units of three state-owned lenders to create the country’s seventh-largest bank.

Pending approval by regulators, the syariah units of Bank Rakyat Indonesia, Bank Mandiri and Bank Negara Indonesia will join forces by February to form a lender with roughly 215 trillion rupiah (S$19.8 billion) in assets – just under half of all Islamic banking assets in the country.

With its extra heft, the new bank will be better placed to raise funds at more competitive rates, S&P said in an analyst note last Thursday.

“The merger will enable the syariah bank to have the capacity to generate more businesses, becoming part of the global sukuk, and having the potential to be ranked among the top 10 global syariah banks based on market capitalisation,” Mr Erick Thohir, Minister of State-owned Enterprises, told The Straits Times in a written comment.

The move is part of an ongoing effort among Indonesian officials to capture a bigger slice of the market of religiously observant Muslims. The market is thought to be worth around US$2.2 trillion, according to the IFSB.

Before the pandemic, islands including Lombok and the autonomous region of Aceh, which has its own syariah-based criminal code, were regularly bandied as potential halal holiday hot spots that can serve as an alternative to Bali.

A 2014 law requiring consumer products and pharmaceuticals to declare whether they comply with Islamic law by avoiding, among other things, pork or alcohol, will begin going into effect in 2022.

Even so, Indonesia’s Islamic banks are struggling under a pile of bad debt just like their conventional counterparts across the country. Dud loans among syariah banks, known as non-performing financing (NPF), stood at 3.3 per cent at the end of July. By comparison, they were 3.22 per cent for all Indonesian banks.

Last year, the NPF at Bank Muamalat, Indonesia’s first syariah bank, neared 5 per cent, resulting in a 3.2 trillion rupiah bailout by a consortium led by Mr Ilham Akbar Habibie, the son of the late former president B.J. Habibie. Analysts say the sector is hamstrung by poor risk management relative to the conventional sector.

By comparison, Malaysia’s syariah banking sector dates back to 1983, predating Indonesia’s by a decade and was part of a concerted official effort to lift living standards among ethnic Malays by coaxing them into opening bank accounts and to borrow.

Loans in Malaysia, too, can be more flexible and are less reliant on collateral, analysts say.

Indonesia’s syariah banks are increasingly a government priority, instead of being left to fend for themselves, Mr Rifki Ismail, assistant director of Bank Indonesia’s department of syariah economics and finance, told The Straits Times.

“We were using a bottom-up approach. Now, it is top-down,” he said. “We are following the success story of Malaysia.”

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on October 19, 2020, with the headline 'Indonesia gains heft in Islamic banking with 3-way merger'. Print Edition | Subscribe