Blocked Suez Canal forces ships to look at costly detours around Africa

Two tugboats attempt to free the stricken Ever Given. Work to refloat the massive container ship has so far been unsuccessful.
Two tugboats attempt to free the stricken Ever Given. Work to refloat the massive container ship has so far been unsuccessful.PHOTO: EPA-EFE

ISMAILIA, EGYPT (BLOOMBERG) - Ships are beginning costly and time-consuming detours around Africa, with the Suez Canal still blocked by a massive container vessel, as concerns mount that a complex rescue mission could extend into weeks.

The prospect of a longer-than-anticipated outage along what is arguably the world's most important maritime trade route threatens further turmoil in a shipping sector that is already scrambling to keep maritime transportation for everything from finished goods to energy and commodities on track.

The stranded mega-container ship is holding up an estimated $9.6 billion (S$12.92 billion) of goods each day, according to shipping data. This works out to US$400 million an hour.

Data from shipping expert Lloyd's List values the canal's west-bound traffic at roughly US$5.1 billion a day, and east-bound daily traffic at around US$4.5 billion. 

Work since Tuesday (March 23) to refloat the stricken Ever Given has so far been unsuccessful, with tugs and diggers failing to budge the giant, 400m long vessel and clear the route for stranded ocean-going carriers hauling billions of dollars worth of oil and consumer goods.

Work to dislodge the massive Ever Given container vessel blocking the Suez Canal will take until at least Wednesday next week, according to people familiar with the rescue efforts.

The task of re-floating the 200,000-ton ship will require more time to dredge sand, said the people, who asked not to be named discussing private details. Initially, the salvage mission had been expected to last only a couple of days.

Dredgers will need to move between 15,000 to 20,000 cubic metres of sand in order to reach a depth of 12 to 16 metres - eight times the size of an Olympic swimming pool - to allow the ship to float, the Suez Canal Authority said on Thursday. 

"In addition to the dredgers already on site a specialised suction dredger is now with the vessel and will shortly begin work. This dredger can shift 2,000 cubic meters of material every hour," Bernhard Schulte Shipmanagement, the technical manager of the Ever Given said in a statement.

If containers can be left aboard the Ever Given, the refloat should be completed by Thursday, aided by higher tides, according to Mr Randy Giveans, senior vice-president of Equity Research for Energy Maritime at Jefferies LLC. Should cargo need to be unloaded or extensive repairs made to the canal itself, "then the downtime could certainly last at least two weeks", he said.

Two liquefied natural gas tankers loaded in the United States and bound for Asian markets appear to have changed course in the mid-Atlantic and are now heading around Africa to avoid gridlock in the Suez waterway.

A.P. Moller-Maersk A/S and Hapag-Lloyd AG are considering sending ships along the same route, moves that would follow a Synergy Marine-managed ship that is being sent around the Cape of Good Hope. Torm A/S, a Danish owner of tankers, said its customers have asked about the cost of options to divert.

Vessels currently outside of the Red Sea that were planning to use the Suez Canal are deciding whether to reroute around Africa, adding 10 to 15 days to their voyages, according to Mr Giveans. Ships queueing on either end of the Suez Canal area are likely to wait to determine how long the passage will be closed before taking a decision to divert, he said.

"Regarding the possible alternatives, we are looking at all of them, including the Cape of Good Hope but also many others, for example air solutions for critical and time-sensitive cargo," Maersk said in a statement.

"No concrete decision has been taken yet. It will depend on how long the Suez Canal remains impassable."

A particular worry for the broader economic impact of the Suez incident are the supply lifelines for European companies ranging from car manufacturers to retailers that rely on a steady flow of Asian imports. The outage comes on top of coronavirus pandemic impacts that have already sowed havoc in supply chains with shortages and delays.

South Korea's HMM Co says it has had a giant vessel waiting outside the Suez Canal to return to Asia since Wednesday.

A list of the cargo aboard gives an indication of the potential for disruption across a swathe of sectors, and includes wood, machinery, frozen beef, paper, powered milk, furniture, beer, frozen pork, auto components, chocolate, and cosmetics.

Caterpillar Inc, the largest US machinery producer, said it is facing shipment delays and is even considering airlifting products if necessary. The US National Security Council is closely monitoring the situation, a spokesman said on Thursday night.

The German container line Hapag-Lloyd said it was closely following "the implications on its services. We are presently looking into possible vessel diversions around Cape of Good Hope."

For the container lines that haul about 80 per cent of global merchandise trade, a prolonged bottleneck between Europe and Asia risks throwing off ship schedules set months in advance so importers can plan their purchases, manage inventories and keep store shelves stocked or production lines running.

The problem compounds with every day container ships have to wait. Vessels that arrive several days late cannot be emptied and reloaded in time to make the scheduled return journey. That leads carriers to cancel trips - further constraining capacity and pushing up freight rates.

Re-routing around South Africa's Cape of Good Hope would add 9,656km to the journey and something like US$300,000 (S$404,200) in fuel costs for a supertanker delivering Middle East oil to Europe.

Owners of supertankers hauling two million-barrel cargoes had been losing money for weeks on the industry's benchmark trade route - a function of Opec+ withholding millions of barrels of supply from the global market.

On Wednesday, though, the carriers nudged back to profitability. Rates for smaller crude-carrying ships are climbing too, and earnings on oil-product vessels sailing from the Middle East to Europe have also jumped.


Work to refloat the stricken Ever Given has so far been unsuccessful. PHOTO: AFP

Fragile infrastructure

"The longer this lasts, the more likely that you'll have that impact," said Mr Brian Gallagher, head of investor relations at Euronav NV, owner of the world's third-largest fleet of supertankers.

"It's more a reminder of the fragility of some of the infrastructure that's out there. That may have a knock-on effect, with people taking the view that they'll take the longer transit for certainty."

Shipbrokers report that oil traders are increasingly hiring tankers with "just-in-case" options to sail around Africa should the blockage drag on. Vessels sailing empty to collect oil in north-west Europe could get delayed, forcing the region's exporters to seek alternative carriers, according to people involved in that market.

Rates to charter oil tankers in some regions have climbed higher since the blockage first appeared. Suezmax vessels, which typically haul one million barrels through the canal are now fetching about US$17,000 a day, the most since June 2020.

If more ships are forced to sail around the southern tip of Africa, that will boost rates as journey times increase.

The canal is currently holding up about two million barrels a day of oil flows, according to Braemar estimates. Congestion is also hitting bulk carriers that ship products from wheat to iron ore. There is a long queue of bulk ships at the moment - just shy of 40 vessels - according to Mr Peter Sand, chief shipping analyst at trade group Bimco.