Sand mining in Vietnam’s Mekong Delta sinks homes, livelihoods and hopes

CAN THO – One summer morning, Ms Le Thi Hong Mai’s home collapsed into a river in Vietnam’s Mekong Delta, where shoreline erosion caused by sand mining and hydropower dams threatens hundreds of thousands of people.

Sand – needed to produce concrete – is the world’s second-most exploited natural resource after water, and its use has trebled in the past two decades, according to the UN Environment Programme.

Vietnam’s “rice bowl” delta region, where the Mekong empties into the South China Sea, is predicted to run out of sand in just over a decade. But losses to the river bed are already devastating lives and harming the local economy.

Ms Mai said she “lost everything”, including the small restaurant business attached to her house in the suburbs of Can Tho city.

“I heard a bang, I rushed out and everything was gone,” recalled the 46-year-old, who was sleeping close by. “I have nothing left”.

Over the past two decades, hydropower dams upstream on the Mekong have restricted the flow of sand to the delta.

And sand mining to feed Vietnam’s construction boom is also fast depleting resources, according to a major World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) report published earlier in 2023.

By 2040, the amount of sediment could be reduced by up to 97 per cent, a 2018 WWF-led Mekong River Commission study said, with serious consequences for people living and working on the shores of the river.

With less sand, river flows become lighter and faster and hit the banks at greater speed, accelerating erosion.

Between 2016 and August 2023, at least 750km of riverbank and nearly 2,000 houses in the Mekong Delta region sank into rivers, government figures show.

‘Last grains of sand’

Along the Mekong, diggers and boats work around the clock, dredging sand from the river bed.

According to Vietnam’s Ministry of Transport, the Delta region needs 54 million cubic m of sand for six major national highways before 2025. The river system can provide less than half, the ministry says.

Important projects have already been delayed while the authorities debate alternatives, including sea sand or imports from neighbouring Cambodia.

In Can Tho, cows sit next to unmanned excavators, and sections of a road that will eventually run to Ca Mau province are still underwater – awaiting sand to cover them.

“We haven’t had enough sand since the beginning of the year, so we don’t have much to do,” said one worker, who declined to give his name.

Vietnam banned exports of sand in all forms in 2017. But given the high domestic demand, the amount dredged still exceeds what comes downstream, Mekong expert Nguyen Huu Thien explained.

At the current extraction rate of 35 million cubic m to 55 million cubic m a year, there will be

no more sand by 2035

, according to the study.

“These are the last grains of sand we are dredging,” Mr Thien said.

‘Nowhere else to go’

In Hau Giang province, 60km from where Ms Mai lost her home, Ms Diep Thi Lua awoke in the middle of the night to see her front garden disappear into the water.

“We all jumped out of bed after hearing a big noise,” the 49-year-old said. “We could feel that the ground was shaking. We were so, so scared.”

She said the river had widened over the decades by dozens of metres.

Since 2016, Vietnam’s government has spent over US$470 million (S$630 million) on 190 projects to prevent erosion in the Mekong Delta, according to the state media.

But “many of these expensive structures have collapsed into the river”, Mr Thien said. A single US$4.7 million embankment built in 2016 was washed away three times between 2020 and 2022, the state media reported.

Half the delta could be gone by the end of the century, Mr Thein warned. “After that, the delta will disappear altogether and we will have to redraw our map and rewrite our geography books.”

Around 20,000 households need to be resettled because of the risks, according to the General Department of Natural Disaster Prevention and Control.

The WWF puts the figure much higher, saying half a million could lose their homes.

But resettlement “requires lots of money, which our government will never have”, said an official from Hau Giang province who did not want to be named. “We know they could lose their lives, living in those high-risk areas, but we have no solutions.”

Residents like Ms Mai and Ms Lua are left gripped by fear.

“I have not slept well since the erosion. We have nowhere else to go. We just have to accept it,” Ms Mai said. AFP