YouTube's stricter election fraud rules shows sharp drop in fake videos

YouTube has lagged behind other platforms in cracking down on different types of misinformation.
YouTube has lagged behind other platforms in cracking down on different types of misinformation.PHOTO: REUTERS

NEW YORK (NYTIMES) YouTube's stricter policies against election misinformation was followed by sharp drops in the prevalence of false and misleading videos on Facebook and Twitter, according to new research released Thursday (Oct 14), underscoring the video service's power across social media.

Researchers at the Centre for Social Media and Politics at New York University found a significant rise in election fraud YouTube videos shared on Twitter immediately after the Nov 3 election. In November, those videos consistently accounted for about one-third of all election-related video shares on Twitter. The top YouTube channels about election fraud that were shared on Twitter that month came from sources that had promoted election misinformation in the past, such as Project Veritas, Right Side Broadcasting Network and One America News Network.

But the proportion of election fraud claims shared on Twitter dropped sharply after Dec 8. That was the day that YouTube said it would remove videos that promoted the unfounded theory that widespread errors and fraud changed the outcome of the presidential election. By Dec 21, the proportion of election fraud content from YouTube that was shared on Twitter had dropped below 20 per cent for the first time since the election.

The proportion fell further after Jan 7, when YouTube announced that any channels that violated its election misinformation policy would receive a "strike," and that channels that received three strikes in a 90-day period would be permanently removed. By Inauguration Day, the proportion was around 5 per cent.

The trend was replicated on Facebook. A post-election surge in sharing videos containing fraud theories peaked at about 18 per cent of all videos on Facebook just before Dec 8. After YouTube introduced its stricter policies, the proportion fell sharply for much of the month, before rising slightly before the Jan 6 riot at the Capitol. The proportion dropped again, to 4 per cent by Inauguration Day, after the new policies were put in place Jan 7.

To reach their findings, researchers collected a random sampling of 10 per cent of all tweets each day. They then isolated tweets that linked to YouTube videos. They did the same for YouTube links on Facebook, using a Facebook-owned social media analytics tool, CrowdTangle.

From this large data set, the researchers filtered for YouTube videos about the election broadly, as well as about election fraud using a set of keywords like Stop the Steal and Sharpiegate. This allowed the researchers to get a sense of the volume of YouTube videos about election fraud over time, and how that volume shifted in late 2020 and early 2021.

Misinformation on major social networks has proliferated in recent years. YouTube in particular has lagged behind other platforms in cracking down on different types of misinformation, often announcing stricter policies several weeks or months after Facebook and Twitter. In recent weeks, however, YouTube has toughened its policies, such as banning all anti-vaccine misinformation and suspending the accounts of prominent anti-vaccine activists, including Joseph Mercola and Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

Ms Ivy Choi, a YouTube spokesman, said that YouTube was the only major online platform with a presidential election integrity policy. "We also raised up authoritative content for election-related search queries and reduced the spread of harmful election-related misinformation," she said.

Ms Megan Brown, a research scientist at the NYU Center for Social Media and Politics, said it was possible that after YouTube banned the content, people could no longer share the videos that promoted election fraud. It is also possible that interest in the election fraud theories dropped considerably after states certified their election results.

But the bottom line, Ms Brown said, is that "we know these platforms are deeply interconnected".

YouTube, she pointed out, has been identified as one of the most-shared domains across other platforms, including in both of Facebook's recently released content reports and NYU's own research.

"It's a huge part of the information ecosystem," Ms Brown said, "so when YouTube's platform becomes healthier, others do as well."