Woman who sued over Subway tuna seeks to quit case; Subway demands sanctions

A California woman sued Subway in January 2021, accusing the chain of using other fish species, chicken, pork and cattle in its tuna products, or no tuna at all. PHOTO: SUBWAY/FACEBOOK

CALIFORNIA – The California woman suing Subway, claiming its tuna products contain ingredients other than tuna, wants to end her lawsuit because she is pregnant, prompting Subway to demand her lawyers be sanctioned for bringing a frivolous case.

Ms Nilima Amin said her “severe” morning sickness and “debilitating” conditions as she prepares for a third child have left her “unable to proceed with the obligations as plaintiff”, and require her to focus on her health and family.

She wants to dismiss the case in San Francisco federal court without prejudice, which would let her sue again when she feels better.

In a May 4 filing, Subway said Ms Amin’s excuse flunked the “straight-face” test, and her lawyers most likely realised it would not “simply pay the windfall settlement that they hoped to get by constructing a high-profile shakedown”.

Subway also said the “media frenzy” from the lawsuit caused severe harm, and faulted Ms Amin’s “ever-changing” theories to debunk its claim that its tuna sandwiches, salads and wraps contained “100 per cent tuna.”

The chain wants her proposed class action dismissed, and her seven lawyers to pay at least $618,000 of its legal bills.

Ms Amin’s lawyers did not immediately respond on Monday to requests for comment.

The plaintiff claimed to have ordered Subway tuna products more than 100 times before suing in January 2021.

She accused Subway of using other fish species, chicken, pork and cattle in its tuna products, or no tuna at all.

Last July, US District Judge Jon Tigar in San Francisco let Ms Amin’s case continue but rejected her claim that “reasonable consumers” would expect only tuna and nothing else, calling it a “fact of life” that ingredients such as mayonnaise were okay.

Subway has nearly 37,000 restaurants in more than 100 countries. REUTERS

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.