French Senate approves tax on big tech firms, as US opens digital levy probe

VIDEO: REUTERS
France has accused Google, Amazon, Facebook and Apple of paying insufficient income tax.
France has accused Google, Amazon, Facebook and Apple of paying insufficient income tax.PHOTO: REUTERS

WASHINGTON (REUTERS) - France’s Senate gave final approval to a tax on big technology companies on Thursday (July 11), potentially opening up a new front in a trade row between Washington and the European Union.

President Donald Trump on Wednesday ordered an investigation into the tax, which could lead to the United States imposing new tariffs or other trade restrictions.

“Between allies, we can and should solve our disputes not by threats but through other ways,” Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire told senators before the final vote.

The 3 per cent levy will apply to revenue from digital services earned in France by firms with more than 25 million euros (S$38 million) in French revenue and 750 million euros worldwide.

It is due to kick in retroactively from the start of 2019.

France pushed ahead with the tax after EU countries failed to agree a levy valid across the bloc in the face of opposition from Ireland, Denmark, Sweden and Finland.

“France is a sovereign country, its decisions on tax matters are sovereign and will continue to be sovereign,” Le Maire said.

Other EU countries including Austria, Britain, Spain and Italy have also announced plans for their own digital taxes.

They say a levy is needed because big, multinational internet companies such as Facebook and Amazon are currently able to book profits in low- tax countries like Ireland, no matter where the revenue originates.

Political pressure to respond has been growing as local retailers in high streets and online have been disadvantaged; French President Emmanuel Macron has said that taxing big tech more heavily is an issue of social justice.

 
 
 

However, Irish Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe said in May that national taxes targeting mostly US-based digital firms were “highly likely to exacerbate global trade tensions and damage cross-border trade and investment”, and would make it harder to reach agreement on a global reform.

The ASIC French lobby representing firms like Facebook, Google, Amazon, Twitter and Airbnb warned of a wider impact.

“By attempting to unilaterally overtax American players, Bruno Le Maire has triggered a trade war that penalises French technology today and will penalise tomorrow many sectors that make the French economy successful, including wine, automobiles and luxury,” ASIC president Giuseppe de Martino said .

TRADE ROW 

The digital tax spat is separate from the transatlantic trade row, but could be used by Trump to try to obtain EU concessions on the trade front.

The United States and the EU have threatened to impose billions of dollars of tit-for-tat tariffs on planes, tractors and food in a nearly 15-year dispute at the World Trade Organisation over aircraft subsidies given to US planemaker Boeing and its European rival, Airbus.

Trump has also imposed new tariffs on imports of EU steel and aluminium – and has threatened punitive duties on cars and auto parts if the two sides fail to reach an overall trade deal.

Plans to launch trade talks between Washington and Brussels have, however, been hampered by US tariffs on steel and by EU states’ reluctance to include farm products in the talks.

The European Commission has estimated that multinational digital companies with investments in the EU are on average taxed at a rate 14 percentage points below that of other firms.

“We are merely re-establishing fiscal justice. We want to create taxation for the 21st century that is fair and efficient,” Le Maire told senators.

“We want to impose on these new business models the same rules that apply to all other economic activities.” 

Paris has pledged to drop its tax as soon as an international accord is reached at the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development on overhauling cross-border tax rules for the digital era. This is expected by the end of 2020.

The French government says the tax does not target US companies and will affect European and Asian firms as well.

The legislation should be enacted within 21 days, a spokeswoman for the Senate said, unless the government or lawmakers ask for a final review by the Constitutional Council.

However, that is unlikely as the bill found wide backing among senators even though some voiced concern about double taxation as corporation tax is based on profit and the digital tax is based on revenues.