US axed CDC expert job in China months before coronavirus outbreak

People wear protective face masks at Lujiazui financial district in Shanghai, China, on March 19, 2020.
People wear protective face masks at Lujiazui financial district in Shanghai, China, on March 19, 2020.PHOTO: REUTERS

WASHINGTON (REUTERS) - Several months before the coronavirus pandemic began, the Trump administration eliminated a key American public health position in Beijing intended to help detect disease outbreaks in China, Reuters has learnt.

The American disease expert, a medical epidemiologist embedded in China's disease control agency, left her post in July, according to four sources with knowledge of the issue.

The first cases of the new coronavirus may have emerged as early as November, and as cases exploded, the Trump administration in February chastised China for censoring information about the outbreak and keeping US experts from entering the country to help.

"It was heartbreaking to watch," said Dr Bao-Ping Zhu, a Chinese American who served in that role, which was funded by the US Centres for Disease Control and Prevention, between 2007 and 2011.

"If someone had been there, public health officials and governments across the world could have moved much faster."

Dr Zhu and the other sources said the American expert, Dr Linda Quick, was a trainer of Chinese field epidemiologists who were deployed to the epicentre of outbreaks to help track, investigate and contain diseases.

As an American CDC employee, they said, Dr Quick was in an ideal position to be the eyes and ears on the ground for the United States and other countries on the coronavirus outbreak, and might have alerted them to the growing threat weeks earlier.

No other foreign disease experts were embedded to lead the programme after Dr Quick left in July, according to the sources. Dr Zhu said an embedded expert can often get word of outbreaks early, after forming close relationships with Chinese counterparts.

Dr Zhu and the other sources said Dr Quick could have provided real-time information to US and other officials around the world during the first weeks of the outbreak, when they said the Chinese government tamped down on the release of information and provided erroneous assessments.

Dr Quick left amid a bitter US trade dispute with China when she learnt her federally funded post, officially known as resident adviser to the US Field Epidemiology Training Programme in China, would be discontinued as of September, the sources said.

The US CDC said it first learned of a "cluster of 27 cases of pneumonia" of unexplained origin in Wuhan, China, on Dec 31.

 
 

Since then, the outbreak of the disease known as Covid-19 has spread rapidly worldwide, killing more than 13,600 people, infecting more than 317,000. The epidemic has overwhelmed healthcare systems in some countries, including Italy, and threatens to do so in the US and elsewhere.

During a press briefing on Sunday shortly after this story was first published, President Donald Trump dismissed the Reuters report as similar to other stories regarding the CDC that he described as "100 per cent wrong", without addressing whether the role had been eliminated.

US CDC director Dr Robert Redfield maintained the agency's presence in China "is actually being augmented as we speak", without elaborating.

In a statement to Reuters before the report was published, the CDC said the elimination of the adviser position did not hinder Washington's ability to get information and "had absolutely nothing to do with CDC not learning of cases in China earlier".

The agency said its decision not to have a resident adviser "started well before last summer and was due to China's excellent technical capability and maturity of the programme".

The CDC said it has assigned two of its Chinese employees as "mentors" to help with the training programme. The agency did not respond to questions about the mentors' specific role or expertise.

The CDC would not make Dr Quick, who still works for the agency, available for comment.

Asked for comment on Chinese transparency and responsiveness to the outbreak, China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs referred Reuters to remarks by spokesman Geng Shuang last Friday (March 20).

Mr Geng said the country "has adopted the strictest, most comprehensive, and most thorough prevention and control measures in an open, transparent, and responsible manner, and informed the (World Health Organisation) and relevant countries and regions of the latest situation in a timely manner".

One disease expert told Reuters he was sceptical that the US resident adviser would have been able to get earlier or better information to the Trump administration, given the Chinese government's suppression of information.

"In the end, based on circumstances in China, it probably wouldn't have made a big difference," Dr Scott McNabb, who was a CDC epidemiologist for 20 years and is now a research professor at Emory University. "The problem was how the Chinese handled it. What should have changed was the Chinese should have acknowledged it earlier and didn't."

ALERT FROM CHINA'S CDC

Mr Alex Azar, secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS) said last Friday that his agency learnt of the coronavirus in early January, based on Dr Redfield's conversations with "Chinese colleagues".

Dr Redfield learnt that "this looks to be a novel coronavirus" from Dr Gao Fu, the head of the China CDC, according to an HHS administration official, who spoke on condition of anonymity.

"Dr Redfield always talked to Dr Gao," the official said.

 
 

HHS and CDC did not make Mr Azar or Dr Redfield available for comment.

Dr Zhu and other sources said US leaders should not have been relying on the China CDC director for alerts and updates. In general, they said, officials in China downplayed the severity of the outbreak in the early weeks and did not acknowledge evidence of person-to-person transmission until Jan 20.

After the epidemic exploded and China had imposed strict quarantines, Trump administration officials complained that the Chinese had censored information about the outbreak and that the US had been unable to get American disease experts into the country to help contain the spread.

Mr Azar told CNN on Feb 14 that he and CDC director Dr Redfield officially offered to send a CDC team into China on Jan 6 but still had not received permission for them to enter the country.

HHS oversees the CDC.

"Dr Redfield and I made the offer on January 6th - 36 days ago, 60,000 cases and 1,300 deaths ago," Mr Azar said. "We made the offer to send the CDC experts in to assist their Chinese colleagues to get to the bottom of key scientific questions like, how transmissible is this disease? What is the severity? What is the incubation period and can there be asymptomatic transmission?"

Days later, the World Health Organisation secured permission to send a team that included two US experts. The team visited between Feb 16 and 24. By then, China had reported more than 75,000 cases.

On Feb 25, the first day the CDC told the American public to prepare for an outbreak at home, US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo accused China of mishandling the epidemic through its "censorship" of medical professionals and media.

Relations between the two countries have deteriorated since then, as Mr Trump has labelled the coronavirus the "Chinese virus" - a description the Chinese have condemned as stigmatising.

Last week, the Chinese government announced that Americans from three US news organisations, The New York Times, Washington Post and Wall Street Journal, would be expelled from China.

ONCE 'FRIENDS', NOW RIVALS

The decision to eliminate Dr Quick's job came as the CDC has scaled back the number of US staff in China over the last two years, the sources told Reuters.

"We had already withdrawn many technical public health experts," the same expert said.

The CDC, however, disputed that staffing was a problem or that its information had been limited by the move. "It was not the staffing shortage that limited our ability" it said.

The US CDC team in Beijing now includes three American citizens in permanent roles, an additional American who is temporary and around 10 Chinese nationals, the agency said. Of the Americans, one is an influenza expert with expertise in respiratory disease. Covid-19 is not influenza, though it can cause severe respiratory illness.

The CDC team, aside from Dr Quick, was housed at US Embassy facilities. No American CDC staffer besides Dr Quick was embedded with China's disease control agency, the sources said.

China in recent weeks has reported a dramatic slowdown in new cases, the result of drastic containment measures including the lockdown of Hubei province, home to 60 million people.

Nevertheless, the infectious disease experts who spoke with Reuters said, the US could use people like Dr Quick with contacts on the ground, especially if fears of a second wave of infections materialises.

Dr Thomas Frieden, a former director of the CDC, said that if the US resident adviser had still been in China, "it is possible that we would know more today about how this coronavirus is spreading and what works best to stop it".

Dr George Conway, a medical epidemiologist who knows Dr Quick and had served as resident adviser between 2012 and 2015, said funding for the position had been tenuous for years because of a perennial debate among US health officials over whether China should be paying for funding its own training programme.

Yet since the training programme was launched in 2001, the sources familiar with it say, it has not only strengthened the ranks of Chinese epidemiologists in the field, but also fostered collegial relationships between public health officials in the two countries.

"We go there as credentialed diplomats and return home as close colleagues and often as friends," Dr Conway said.

In 2007, Dr Robert Fontaine, a CDC epidemiologist and one of the longest serving US officials in the adviser's position, received China's highest honour for outstanding contributions to public health due to his contribution as a foreigner in helping to detect and investigate clusters of pneumonia of unknown cause.

But since last year, Dr Frieden and others said, growing tensions between the Trump administration and China's leadership have apparently damaged the collaboration.

"The message from the administration was, 'Don't work with China, they're our rival,'" Dr Frieden said.

Mr Trump's re-election campaign sent out a statement on Sunday evening dismissing controversy about the CDC's cut as a matter of politics.

"Democrats are eager to politicise the coronavirus crisis and weaponise it against President Trump, the statement said. "In so doing, they're siding with the Chinese and providing cover for Beijing's cover-up."