Trump rebuffs Biden transition team, setting off Covid-19 and national security risks

Mr Trump's stonewalling is already creating modest risks in the president-elect's dealings with foreign leaders. PHOTO: EPA-EFE

WASHINGTON (NYTIMES) - United States President Donald Trump's refusal to allow President-elect Joe Biden and his transition staff access to government offices, secure communications and classified briefings prompted growing warnings on Thursday (Nov 12), including from Republicans, that keeping Mr Biden in the dark potentially endangers the country.

On Capitol Hill, several Senate Republicans insisted that Mr Biden should at least be given access to the President's Daily Brief, the compendium of the nation's most closely guarded intelligence secrets and assessments of threats like terrorist plots and cyber attack vulnerabilities.

Their call amounted to an acknowledgment that Mr Biden would be declared the victor in the election.

"I don't think they need to know everything," Senator Roy Blunt of Missouri, a member of the Senate Republican leadership, said of Mr Biden's advisers. "I think they do need to know some things, and national security would be one of them."

"President-elect Biden should be receiving intelligence briefings right now; that is really important," said Senator Susan Collins, a member of the Intelligence Committee and one of the few Senate Republicans to publicly acknowledge Mr Biden's victory. "It's probably the most important part of the transition."

Giving Mr Biden and his top aides access to the daily briefing, as Mr Trump got right after his election four years ago, would address only a fraction of the problem.

Mr Biden will confront an array of complex dilemmas: bruised relationships with foreign allies, a weak economy and sluggish recovery, perhaps the most high-risk period yet of the coronavirus, and a need to distribute a vaccine to 330 million Americans.

The President-elect's team is concerned that it is being shut out of planning for the vaccine distribution, a huge undertaking that the incoming administration expects to inherit the moment Mr Biden is sworn in.

His advisers said they have not had access to the details of Warp Speed, the project that has vaccine distribution planning well under way, and understand little about its workings.

It is focusing on logistical challenges and policy questions, one senior Biden adviser said, like how to prioritse who gets a vaccine and how to make distribution equitable along racial and socioeconomic lines - a priority of Mr Biden's, but one rarely discussed by Mr Trump.

"Every day Senate Republicans continue to indulge the President in the delusion he didn't just lose the election, they are undermining faith in our democracy, putting our national security at risk and impeding the response to the Covid-19 health and economic crises," said Senator Chuck Schumer of New York, the Democratic leader.

Mr Trump's stonewalling is already creating modest risks in the President-elect's dealings with foreign leaders: Mr Biden made his first contacts on unsecured telephone lines, without State Department translators or briefings about what those leaders might seek from him.

Aides to Mr Biden said that so far, the risks were manageable. Mr Biden's decades of experience in Washington, including 17 years as chair or ranking member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, means little will take him by surprise.

But given the global tumult in the past four years, as one Biden adviser put it: "The risk is that we don't know what we don't know."

Deprived of access to secure government communications by the Trump administration, Mr Biden's team of more than 500 former officials and outside experts has embraced workarounds, talking over encrypted apps like Signal to shield their conversations from the Chinese and meeting in outdoor coffee shops with government officials they once worked alongside.

The conversations are circumspect because of rules on both sides limiting their exchanges of information, participants said. But the Biden team will be relying on deep connections and old friendships that have kept up throughout the Trump administration, often with parts of the bureaucracy that Mr Trump has referred to as the "deep state".

It may be weeks until Mr Biden's agency review teams, made up of long-time government officials with deep roots in the bureaucracy, are let into the government departments that a Biden administration will run from noon on Jan 20.

Some issues can wait until a formal "ascertainment" is declared, giving them access to the offices and classified material that some parts of the administration have prepared, including the Department of Homeland Security and the intelligence agencies.

Combating Covid-19 may be the most urgent issue for Mr Biden. His team hopes to carry out a national testing strategy, but it will have to start from scratch because the Trump administration does not have one.

Biden advisers are seeking guidance from groups including the Rockefeller Foundation, which has drafted a national testing plan and is partnering states and cities to expand testing efforts.

And access to the Trump vaccine distribution plan will become increasingly important as Mr Biden's inauguration approaches so his team can take over without any hiccups, said the senior adviser, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss internal transition details.

Republican Senator Lisa Murkowski of Alaska said she believed the Trump administration should share vaccine distribution plans with Mr Biden, ensuring that "as the President-elect is able to come in and bring with him a transition team, that there is that flow of information that we typically see when we have transitions".

Other matters also have a short time fuse. The last remaining arms control treaty between the United States and Russia, called the New START treaty, expires days after the inauguration.

Mr Biden has expressed a willingness to renew it, but his national security staff has had no access to the detailed discussions between National Security Adviser Robert O'Brien and his Kremlin counterpart, or to a team of State Department negotiators who have dealt with Russia on questions like future inspections and verification.

An array of newer threats persist as well, like terrorist plots or brewing cyber attacks.

The 9/11 commission concluded that the short transition caused by the Florida recount in 2000 hampered the Bush administration's ability to deal with Al-Qaeda plots. At the time, President-elect George W. Bush discussed the dangers of abbreviated briefings in an interview with The New York Times at his ranch eight days before his first inauguration.

With Mr Trump unwilling to recognise the election result and authorise the ascertainment that allows formal transition to begin, the White House Communications Agency is forbidden to run secure lines to Mr Biden's house in Delaware. That creates a risk that some of his conversations could be vulnerable to foreign eavesdropping.

His team cannot use the government transition e-mail system, and intelligence agencies have warned that the transition operation is a prime target for Chinese, Russian, North Korean, Iranian and other hackers.

The refusal of the General Services Administration to recognise Mr Biden as the president-elect has also all but halted transition work inside the Pentagon and intelligence agencies.

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.