In pulpits and pews, Catholic churches in the US urge compassion for immigrants

HOBOKEN, New Jersey – The Reverend Alex Santora ascended to the pulpit of the Church of Our Lady of Grace and St Joseph, looked out at the people gathered beneath stained glass and soaring gothic columns that were created largely by Irish immigrants in the 19th century, and told a story of a local immigrant in modern times.

The man came from Cuba more than 40 years ago, started a business and raised a family.

But he had some minor legal trouble in the 1980s. And in 2025, Immigration and Customs Enforcement came for him. He had to close his business, lay off his workers and leave the United States.

“In the last 10 months, we’re hearing about a lot of pain, people whose lives are abandoned and ruined, and not just a few,” Rev Santora told parishioners at the church in Hoboken, New Jersey, during Mass late on Nov 15.

In humble rural churches and tall urban cathedrals across the country this weekend, Catholic priests and parishioners reflected on the Trump administration’s sweeping immigration crackdown.

Some said the roundup of hundreds of thousands of people, which has disproportionately affected Catholic congregations full of immigrants, goes against Christian teachings.

Just a few kilometres from Our Lady of Grace, Rev Santora said, about 1,000 immigrants were being held in a detention centre.

“This is not what Jesus Christ would want,” he told his flock. “It’s immoral.”

The Trump administration says its immigration enforcement campaign will break deportation records by the end of 2025.

Teams of agents, often using military-style equipment,

have raided

factories, construction sites and apartment blocks and detained people at schools, churches and big-box stores.

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) said in late October that it has deported 527,000 “illegal aliens” so far in 2025 and pushed another 1.6 million to leave the United States voluntarily.

A record 66,000 immigrants were in federal detention, according to the agency. DHS spokeswoman Tricia McLaughlin said in October: “This is just the beginning.”

As the administration has stepped up its deportation efforts, though, the Catholic Church has gotten louder in its criticism.

The US Conference of Catholic Bishops on Nov 12 issued a special message – the first since 2013 – opposing what it called the “indiscriminate mass deportation of people”.

“We are saddened by the state of contemporary debate and the vilification of immigrants,” the bishops wrote. “We are concerned about the conditions in detention centres and the lack of access to pastoral care.”

At the end of their message, they said, “we pray for an end to dehumanising rhetoric and violence, whether directed at immigrants or at law enforcement”.

DHS said it is focused on “removing the worst of the worst criminal illegal aliens from American communities, including murderers, rapists, paedophiles, drug dealers and more”.

The agency said 70 per cent of arrests were of immigrants charged with or convicted of a crime in the US. But an analysis of federal data by The New York Times shows that fewer than 40 per cent had a criminal conviction, and only about 8 per cent had been convicted of a violent crime.

In Hoboken, Rev Santora pointed around the church, speaking about how Our Lady of Grace was built by immigrants more than a century ago.

“Their nickels, dimes and quarters built this church. They employed all the people who designed, engineered, constructed and furnished it,” he said.

“We know that immigrants have built our country, and they fuel our economy,” he added.

‘Am I next?’

At the Church of St Mary in nearby Rutherford, Cardinal Joseph Tobin, 73, was presiding over a Sunday afternoon Mass after returning from the US Council of Bishops meeting.

After Mass, he described the moment when the bishops agreed to the content of their letter about the immigration crisis as the greatest show of unanimity he has ever seen in the body. “And when the final vote count was flashed up on the screen in the meeting hall, people spontaneously stood up and applauded,” he said.

“We’re concerned about what we see going on in the country,” the cardinal added. “While we certainly do not deny the obligation of a state to regulate its borders, everyone from the Holy Father and several Holy Fathers down have made it quite clear that having laws isn’t enough. They have to be based on compassion and justice.”

Across the Hudson River in New York City, at the Church of St Francis Xavier in Manhattan, the Reverend Kenneth Boller also addressed the bishops’ letter during Mass.

“The church is like a mother. When the world sees threats, she sees children. When walls are built, she builds bridges,” Rev Boller said. “She knows that her proclamation in the Gospel is credible only when it is translated into gestures of closeness and welcome. And she knows that in every rejected migrant, it is Christ himself.”

At St Thomas Mission in Brownsville, Texas, the Reverend Joel Flores did not directly mention the letter.

But he said in an interview before Mass that there is nothing new in the bishops’ statement about immigration, adding: “It’s a statement the church has been making since its conception.”

“Any institution which does something against the value of human life is worthy of the church making a statement,” Rev Flores said.

Deportations have put his parish in the Rio Grande Valley, which has a high number of Spanish-speaking immigrants, on edge.

Rev Flores said there has been a significant drop in the number of people attending Mass in recent months because parishioners fear they will be picked up by federal agents.

“There’s a system that is deporting or potentially deporting people indiscriminately,” he said. “People are asking questions like, why me, or why them, or am I next?” NYTIMES