Coronavirus pandemic

Dazed and confused? It could be due to coronavirus

WASHINGTON • A pattern is emerging among Covid-19 patients arriving at hospitals in New York: Beyond a fever, cough and shortness of breath, some are deeply disoriented to the point of not knowing where they are or what year it is.

At times, this is linked to low oxygen levels in their blood, but in certain patients, the confusion appears disproportionate to how their lungs are faring.

Dr Jennifer Frontera, a neurologist at NYU Langone Hospital - Brooklyn who has been seeing these patients, told Agence France-Presse the findings were raising concerns about the impact of the coronavirus on the brain and nervous system.

By now, most people are familiar with the respiratory hallmarks of the Covid-19 disease that has infected more than 2.3 million people around the world. But more unusual signs are surfacing in new reports from the front lines.

A study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association recently found 36.4 per cent of 214 Chinese patients had neurological symptoms ranging from loss of smell and nerve pain, to seizures and strokes. A paper in the New England Journal of Medicine last week examining 58 patients in Strasbourg, France, found that more than half were confused or agitated, with brain imaging suggesting inflammation.

"You've been hearing that this is a breathing problem, but it also affects what we most care about, the brain," Dr Andrew Josephson, chair of the neurology department at the University of California, San Francisco, said. "If you become confused, if you're having problems thinking, those are reasons to seek medical attention," he added.

"The old mantra of 'Don't come in unless you're short of breath' probably doesn't apply any more."

It is not completely surprising to scientists that Sars-CoV-2 might impact the brain and nervous system, since this has been documented in other viruses, including HIV, which can cause cognitive decline if untreated.

Viruses affect the brain in one of two main ways, explained Dr Michel Toledano, a neurologist at Mayo Clinic in Minnesota. One is by triggering an abnormal immune response known as a cytokine storm that causes inflammation of the brain - called autoimmune encephalitis. The second is direct infection of the brain, called viral encephalitis.

The brain is protected by something called the blood-brain barrier, which blocks foreign substances but could be breached if compromised. However, since loss of smell is a common symptom of the coronavirus, some have hypothesised the nose might be the pathway to the brain.

This remains unproven - and the theory is somewhat undermined by the fact that many patients experiencing anosmia (loss of smell) do not go on to have severe neurological symptoms.

In the case of the novel coronavirus, doctors believe - based on the current evidence - the neurological impacts are more likely the result of overactive immune response rather than brain invasion.

To prove the latter even happens, the virus must be detected in cerebrospinal fluid. This has been documented once, in a 24-year-old Japanese man whose case was published in the International Journal of Infectious Disease. The man developed confusion and seizures, and imaging showed his brain was inflamed.

But since this is the only known case so far, and the virus test has not yet been validated for spinal fluid, scientists remain cautious.

All of this emphasises the need for more research. Dr Frontera, who is also a professor at NYU School of Medicine, is part of an international collaborative research project to standardise data collection.

Her team is documenting striking cases including seizures in Covid-19 patients with no prior history of the episodes, and "unique" new patterns of tiny brain haemorrhages.

"We're seeing a lot of... (patients) in confused states," Dr Rohan Arora, a neurologist at the Long Island Jewish Forest Hills hospital said, adding that the condition applies to more than 40 per cent of recovered virus patients.

It is not yet known if the impairment is long term, and being in the intensive care unit itself can be a disorienting experience as a result of factors including strong medications. But returning to normal seems to be taking longer than for people who suffer heart failure or stroke, said Dr Arora.


A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on April 20, 2020, with the headline 'Dazed and confused? It could be due to coronavirus'. Subscribe