Man pictured naked in his yard on Google Street View wins compensation
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox
An appeals court in Argentina concluded the man’s dignity had been flagrantly violated.
PHOTO: REUTERS
Follow topic:
- An Argentinian man was captured naked in his garden by a Google camera in 2017, leading to widespread ridicule.
- A lower court initially dismissed the case, but appeals judges ruled Google violated the man's dignity by capturing the image in his private garden.
- Google was ordered to pay the man approximately $12,500, with the court citing their policy of blurring faces as evidence of awareness of privacy.
AI generated
BUENOS AIRES - An Argentine captured naked in his yard by a Google Street View camera
The policeman had sought payment from the internet giant for harm to his dignity, arguing he was behind a 2m-high wall when a Google camera captured him in the buff, from behind, in a small-town in Argentina in 2017.
His house number and street name were also laid bare, broadcast on Argentine TV covering the story, and shared widely on social media.
The man claimed the invasion exposed him to ridicule at work and among his neighbours.
Another court in 2024 dismissed the man’s claim for damages, ruling he only had himself to blame for “walking around in inappropriate conditions in the garden of his home.”
Google, for its part, claimed the perimeter wall was not high enough.
Appeals judges, however, concluded the man’s dignity had been flagrantly violated, and awarded him an amount in Argentine pesos equivalent to about US$12,500 (S$16,000), payable by Google.
“This involves an image of a person that was not captured in a public space but within the confines of their home, behind a fence taller than the average-sized person. The invasion of privacy... is blatant,” they wrote.
The judges said “there is no doubt that in this case there was an arbitrary intrusion into another’s life.”
And they found there was “no justification for (Google) to evade responsibility for this serious error that involved an intrusion into the plaintiff’s house, within his private domain, undermining his dignity.
“No one wants to appear exposed to the world as the day they were born.”
The judges pointed to Google’s policy of blurring the faces and licence plates of people and vehicles photographed for Street View as evidence it was aware of a duty to avoid harm to third parties.
But in this case, “it was not his face that was visible but his entire naked body, an image that should also have been prevented.”
The court absolved co-accused telecoms company Cablevision SA and news site El Censor of liability for the image spreading, saying their actions had “helped highlight the misstep committed by Google.” AFP
