Israel’s war Cabinet minister Gantz says he’ll quit unless Netanyahu moves to new war plan

JERUSALEM – Mr Benny Gantz, an Israeli opposition leader in the country’s three-man war Cabinet, said on May 18 that if Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu does not offer a new plan to bring back hostages and end Hamas’ rule in Gaza by June 8, he will leave the government. 

Mr Gantz’s departure would greatly increase already mounting pressure on Mr Netanyahu seven months after the Hamas attack shocked Israel and led it to wage an unforgiving war in Gaza. It would not on its own collapse the ruling coalition, which has 64 seats out of a 120-seat Parliament. 

Mr Netanyahu instantly rejected the demand.

“The conditions set by Benny Gantz are washed-up words whose meaning is clear: The end of war and defeat for Israel, abandoning most of the hostages, leaving Hamas intact and the establishment of a Palestinian state,” Mr Netanyahu said in a statement. 

Israel’s military is trying to destroy Hamas fighting units in Gaza’s southern city of Rafah – an operation that has already forced half a million Palestinians to flee – and Mr Netanyahu was indignant that in the midst of the fighting Mr Gantz is threatening to break up the Cabinet. 

It is no secret that Mr Gantz and Defence Minister Yoav Gallant have been

barely on speaking terms with Mr Netanyahu

in recent weeks over his management of the war and the way he has alienated US President Joe Biden and his administration, which oppose the Rafah operation.

US National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan is due in Israel on May 19 after

visiting Saudi Arabia

. He has been working to advance a deal that would normalise relations between the two countries, but would require a path to nationhood for Palestinians – a condition Mr Netanyahu has rejected repeatedly. 

Mr Gantz responded to Mr Netanyahu in a later statement, saying “there is no intention to establish a Palestinian state and the Saudis are not demanding that”.

A US official declined to comment on Israeli domestic politics but said the Biden administration has made it clear in public that Israel’s military operation requires a political plan to achieve the defeat of Hamas. 

On May 15, Mr Gallant gave his own statement accusing Mr Netanyahu of failing to create a so-called day-after plan for Gaza, saying Israel was headed towards re-occupying the territory, which he considers unacceptable. Mr Gantz offered his support for Mr Gallant shortly thereafter.

At his press event on May 18, Mr Gantz went much further,

laying out a long list of demands

. He made reference to the war Cabinet’s initial successes, saying it has now fallen apart.

“For many months, unity was indeed real and meaningful,” he said.

“But lately something has gone sour. Essential decisions were not made. Acts of leadership required to ensure victory were not taken. A small minority has taken over the command bridge of the Israeli ship and is leading it into a concrete wall.” 

He added: “Personal and political considerations began to penetrate the holy of holies – Israel’s security.”

The opposition’s complaints against Mr Netanyahu are that he has allowed his far-right coalition partners to dictate policy simply so that he can stay in power, ignoring entreaties by the US and Arab nations, including Saudi Arabia. 

But Mr Netanyahu says that only after Hamas is defeated and Gazans are no longer afraid of it can a plan for the future emerge. 

Mr Gantz listed numerous demands, including defeating Hamas, demilitarising Gaza and bringing in a coalition of Arabs, Palestinians, Americans and Europeans to manage civilian affairs in the ravaged coastal strip.

He said Israelis who have been evacuated from the north because of ongoing battles with Lebanon’s Hezbollah need to be returned to their homes by September.

He also said Mr Netanyahu needs to promote relations with Saudi Arabia and come up with an elusive plan for conscripting religious men. 

Otherwise, he said, “if you choose to follow the path of fanatics and lead the entire nation to the abyss, we will be forced to resign from the government”.

He said he would “turn to the people and establish a government that will win the people’s trust”.

How exactly he can do that remains unclear. One way may be if five members of Mr Netanyahu’s own Likud party can be persuaded to oppose him, which could collapse the government and require elections. 

Mr Gantz, 64, who has been consistently polling ahead of Mr Netanyahu as a future prime minister, turned to the camera to address the nation’s leader personally. 

“I have known you for many years as an Israeli leader and patriot: You know very well what needs to be done. The Netanyahu of a decade ago would have done the right thing. Are you able to do the right and patriotic thing today?” he said.

Mr Netanyahu, 74, is the country’s longest-serving prime minister. After being indicted for bribery and fraud five years ago, centrist politicians increasingly declined to serve with him, and he turned to parties on the extreme right to build his most recent government in late 2022.

The war began when Hamas broke into Israel on Oct 7, killing 1,200 and kidnapping 250 to Gaza.

Israel’s response, aimed at uprooting Hamas as a military and political entity, has destroyed whole neighbourhoods and killed some 35,000 people, according to Hamas officials who do not distinguish between fighters and civilians.

Hamas is considered a terrorist organisation by the US and European Union. BLOOMBERG