US lawmakers accuse Amazon's Jeff Bezos and others of possibly lying to Congress

Amazon founder Jeff Bezos is among those named in a letter by five members of the US House Judiciary Committee. PHOTO: REUTERS

LONDON (REUTERS) - Five members of the US House Judiciary Committee wrote to Amazon's chief executive on Sunday (Oct 17), accusing the company's top executives, including founder Jeff Bezos, of either misleading Congress or possibly lying to it about Amazon's business practices.

The letter also states that the committee is considering "whether a referral of this matter to the Department of Justice for criminal investigation is appropriate".

Addressed to Amazon CEO Andy Jassy, the letter followed a Reuters investigation last week that showed that the company had conducted a systematic campaign of copying products and rigging search results in India to boost sales of its own brands - practices Amazon has denied engaging in.

Mr Jassy, a long-time Amazon executive, succeeded Mr Bezos in July.

The letter states that "credible reporting" in the Reuters story and recent articles in several other news outlets "directly (contradict) the sworn testimony and representations of Amazon's top executives - including former CEO Jeffrey Bezos".

"At best, this reporting confirms that Amazon's representatives misled the committee. At worst, it demonstrates that they may have lied to Congress in possible violation of federal criminal law," the letter says.

In response, an Amazon spokesman issued a statement saying: "Amazon and its executives did not mislead the committee, and we have denied and sought to correct the record on the inaccurate media articles in question."

It adds: "As we have previously stated, we have an internal policy, which goes beyond that of any other retailer's policy that we're aware of, that prohibits the use of individual seller data to develop Amazon private label products. We investigate any allegations that this policy may have been violated and take appropriate action."

Since 2019, the House Judiciary Committee has been investigating competition in digital markets, including how Amazon uses proprietary seller data from its platform, and whether the company unfairly favours its own products.

In sworn testimony before the committee's antitrust subcommittee last year, Mr Bezos said the company prohibits its employees from using data on individual sellers to benefit its own private-label product lines.

In another hearing in 2019, Amazon's associate general counsel Nate Sutton testified that the company does not use such data to create its own branded products or alter its search results to benefit them.

When asked during the 2019 congressional hearing whether Amazon alters algorithms to direct consumers to its own goods, Mr Sutton replied: "The algorithms are optimised to predict what customers want to buy regardless of the seller."

The lawmakers' letter gives Mr Jassy "a final opportunity" to provide evidence to corroborate the company's prior testimony and statements. It also notes that "it is criminally illegal to knowingly and wilfully make statements that are materially false, conceal a material fact, or otherwise provide false documentation in response to a congressional investigation".

It gives the CEO until Nov 1 to provide a sworn response to clarify "how Amazon uses non-public individual seller data to develop and market its own line of products" and how Amazon's search rankings favour those products.

It also requests copies of all documents mentioned in the Oct 13 Reuters investigation.

"We strongly encourage you to make use of this opportunity to correct the record and provide the committee with sworn, truthful, and accurate responses to this request as we consider whether a referral of this matter to the Department of Justice for criminal investigation is appropriate," the letter states.

The Reuters probe was based on thousands of pages of internal Amazon documents - including e-mails, strategy papers and business plans.

They showed that, at least in India, Amazon had a formal, clandestine policy of manipulating search results to favour Amazon's own products, as well as copying other sellers' goods - and that at least two senior company executives had reviewed it.

In response to the Reuters report, Amazon said, "We believe these claims are factually incorrect and unsubstantiated."

The company did not elaborate. It said the way it displays search results does not favour private-brand products.

The lawmakers' letter also cites other recent stories in the Markup, The Wall Street Journal and the Capitol Forum about Amazon's private-brand products and use of seller data.

The letter's sharp wording ratchets up the rhetoric between Washington and Big Tech. Companies including Amazon, Facebook, Apple and Alphabet's Google have been under growing scrutiny in Washington, Europe and other parts of the world, fuelled by concerns among regulators, lawmakers and consumer groups that the firms have too much power and are engaging in unfair practices that hurt other businesses.

The lawmakers' letter was signed by a bipartisan group, and included the judiciary committee's chairman, Democrat Jerrold Nadler, and four members of the antitrust subcommittee - its chair, Democrat David Cicilline, vice-chair Pramila Jayapal and Republicans Ken Buck and Matt Gaetz.

On Wednesday, following publication of the Reuters investigation, US Democratic Senator Elizabeth Warren, a prominent critic of Amazon, called for breaking up the company.

In India, a group representing millions of bricks-and-mortar retailers urged Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government to take action against Amazon.

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.