Corporate ‘net-zero’ pledges lack credibility, research shows

PARIS – Nearly half of the world’s biggest companies have pledged to erase their carbon footprints by around mid-century, but

only a handful have credible game plans

for doing so, climate policy research groups said on Monday.

Without tangible action from firms, the Net-Zero Stocktake 2023 report warned, capping global warming at tolerable levels will likely remain out of reach.

Barely 1 deg C of warming to date has made extreme weather more destructive and deadly, and United Nations climate experts have said the world could breach the

Paris treaty limit of 1.5 deg C

above the pre-industrial benchmark within a decade.

“The big question is whether existing net-zero targets will acquire the measures of credibility quickly enough to keep the Paris Agreement’s temperature goals within reach,” co-author John Lang from the Energy & Climate Intelligence Unit told AFP.

Taking into account national, regional and corporate pledges, some 90 per cent of the global economy has climbed on board the “net-zero” bandwagon, up from 15 per cent in 2019.

In business, 929 companies on the Forbes 2000 list have set targets to eliminate their emissions by around 2050, more than twice as many as in December 2020.

But measuring these CO2-purging pledges against the yardstick of half-a-dozen standards for assessing net-zero claims shows that almost all fall down badly on the details.

“Most entities that have pledged net-zero do not meet minimum requirements for what good net-zero looks like,” said Mr Lang.

Only 4 per cent of corporate commitments are in line with five “starting line” criteria set out in the UN Race to Zero guidelines, one of the voluntary standards.

These basic benchmarks include setting a specific net-zero target; covering greenhouse gases other than CO2, such as methane and nitrous oxide; very limited use of carbon offsets, such as planting trees, instead of emissions reductions; and annual reporting on progress towards both interim and long-term targets.

Arguably no sector is under more pressure to decarbonise than fossil fuel companies, and 75 of the 112 largest of these firms have net-zero targets today, 50 per cent more than a year ago.

But most of these targets are “largely meaningless”, the report said, because they do not include so-called Scope 3 emissions – downstream impacts such as CO2 released by the burning of oil, gas or coal.

Overall, barely a third of corporate net-zero targets examined included Scope 3.

‘No rowing back’

As pressure mounts, signs of a backlash against net-zero commitments have emerged across the corporate landscape.

In May, half a dozen members of the Net-Zero Insurance Alliance, launched in 2021, backed out of the group, and some large institutional investors have softened their net-zero pledges as well.

“People are realising that it’s not a fad, and as they turn their attention to the ‘how’ of net-zero we are seeing pushback,” said Mr Lang.

“But there’s no rowing back from where we are now,” he added. “This is now a norm for the corporate world.”

Gradually, voluntary compliance schemes will give way to regulations and shifts in market-based incentives, Mr Lang predicted.

Already today, the Inflation Reduction Act in the United States and the Net-Zero Industry Act in the European Union are shifting hundreds of billions of dollars from carbon-polluting to clean energy.

Even the fossil fuel industry is not immune to mounting pressure as the decarbonisation of the global economy accelerates.

In 2023, more than US$1.7 trillion (S$2.3 trillion) will be invested in carbon-free energy, compared with US$1 trillion going into energy and power from oil, gas and coal, according to the International Energy Agency. For the first time, investment in solar power will outstrip that in oil in 2023.

And some incumbent energy firms, such as Danish multinational Orsted, have successfully transitioned from fossil fuels to renewables.

“Slowly but surely, the narrative is changing,” said Mr Lang. “I do think we will live to see the day when the social licence to operate of fossil fuel companies will be withdrawn.”

The NewClimate Institute, Oxford Net Zero and Driven EnviroLab also contributed to the Net Zero Stocktake 2023 report. AFP