Calls for Saudi arms embargo pit EU values against interests

A protester holding a placard that says "Decisions that kill" during a demonstration to demand the halting of arms sales to Saudi Arabia, in Madrid on Oct 24, 2018. PHOTO: REUTERS

BRUSSELS/PARIS/BERLIN (REUTERS) - Pressure is growing for the European Union to consider an arms embargo on Saudi Arabia after Germany, Austria and the European Parliament called for an end to weapons sales over the killing of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi.

In the space of a few hours that highlighted tensions over the matter, Germany's Angela Merkel reaffirmed last Friday (Oct 26) that her country would not deliver any arms to Saudi Arabia until Mr Khashoggi's death was explained, while French President Emmanuel Macron said such moves smacked of populist "demagoguery".

EU ambassadors may formally discuss the issue after a rare request to do so by governments, two diplomats said last Friday, and the Netherlands is lobbying for a new EU regime to sanction human rights abuses, regardless of where they happen.

But the debate in Brussels and in EU capitals is also reviving familiar splits in the bloc's foreign policy, with Europe's main powers following their own economic and political interests that tend to undermine any forceful EU foreign policy that aims to be guided by democracy and human rights.

The murder of Mr Khashoggi, a Washington Post columnist, inside the Saudi consulate in Istanbul on Oct 2 has sparked global outrage, become a crisis for the world's top oil exporting state and underscored how Western powers are allied to an Arab kingdom that enforces floggings and the death penalty for dissent.

The Belgian region of Wallonia, which owns firearms manufacturer FN Herstal, has said it will examine future requests for arms export licences to its top weapons client with "the greatest circumspection", following Mr Khashoggi's murder.

Austria, which holds the EU's six-month presidency, wants a halt to arms sales, and Germany will stop approving weapons exports until Mr Khashoggi's murder is cleared up. France ignored such calls.

Mr Macron went further last Friday, saying there was no link between arms sales and the killing of Mr Khashoggi, a prominent critic of de facto Saudi ruler Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman.

"That's pure demagoguery to say 'we must stop arms sales'. It's got nothing to do with Mr Khashoggi," he told reporters during a trip in Slovakia, while not ruling out other coordinated sanctions against those held responsible.

British Prime Minister Theresa May said lastWednesday that Britain's weapons exports to Saudi Arabia met national and EU arms export licensing rules.

Spain, meanwhile, is trying to go ahead with the sale of 400 bombs in order to protect a Saudi contract with a shipyard in the Andalusia region that would create 5,000 jobs.

"If Austria is proposing this ban, then ask how many weapons Austria sells to Saudi Arabia," said a senior EU diplomat.


Though Austria has a substantial arms industry, it sold a meagre €1.4 million (S$2.2 million) of arms and ammunition to Saudi Arabia in 2017, according to EU data.

Germany approved around €400 million worth of arms supplies to Saudi Arabia in the first nine months of 2018.

Last year, Germany sold €351 million worth of aircraft, including helicopters and planes, to Saudi Arabia, though EU data does not specify how much of that is military.

German weapons account for under 2 per cent of Saudi Arabia's arms purchases.

Britain exported military goods to Saudi Arabia worth £1.1 billion (S$1.95 billion) in 2017, according to UK parliamentary papers, while tiny Belgium and Luxembourg combined for €184 million in arms sales to the Saudis last year.

France sold Saudi Arabia €1.8 billion in planes, helicopters and other aerospace equipment in 2017, an amount that has climbed over the past decade, EU data shows, though again it does not say what part of that is military.

"The sale of weapons is something very political and part of a long-term vision," said Ms Camille Lons, a researcher at the European Council on Foreign Relations think tank.

Ms Lons cited Libya, Syria and even the Sahel region, where France, which has thousands of troops on the ground, has sought Saudi help to finance local African forces.

At the heart of Mr Macron's strategy is Crown Prince Mohammed, often referred to as MBS, the 33-year-old Saudi de facto leader who has painted himself as a reformer but is under scrutiny over his potential involvement in Mr Khashoggi's seizure and death.

"It's easy for (German Chancellor Angela) Merkel to come out with this when she sells weapons everywhere except Saudi Arabia," a senior French diplomat told Reuters. "When you see global weapons sales, Germany is one of the largest in the world over the last couple of years, but Saudi isn't much."

A German government spokesman welcomed Austria's initiative last Friday, but declined to comment when asked if German and Austria were isolated on their position within the EU.

Dr Merkel vowed again last Friday to halt all German arms exports to Saudi Arabia until Mr Khashoggi's killing was explained.

One face-saving move for the EU could be to sanction Saudi individuals accused of the Khashoggi murder and separate the issue from its close ties with the Saudi state.

EU governments recently agreed a mechanism to punish chemical weapons attacks by targeting people regardless of their nationality.

They could set up a similar system for human rights abuses.

The United States has its Magnitsky human rights act that covers abusers in any country, named after Mr Sergei Magnitsky, a 37-year-old Russian whistle-blower who died in prison.

"France and Germany have to deal with the big issue of arms exports. Something EU governments could do is to establish a Magnitsky-type act to react," said Ms Rebecca Harms, a Green member of the European Parliament.

She helped spearhead the assembly's resolution calling for an arms embargo and sanctions this week.

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.