For subscribers
Sporting Life
Lionel Messi versus Pele? In all sports, comparing eras just doesn’t work
Golf courses are longer, running shoes are lighter, rackets are more powerful and swimming pools are scientifically designed. So how do we equate generations in sport?
Sign up now: Get the biggest sports news in your inbox
With football’s World Cup imminent, we’re going to dust off ancient disputes. Someone’s going to smirk that Pele’s (right) no Maradona and neither is Lionel Messi (left).
PHOTOS: REUTERS, DOMINIC WONG
- Comparing athletes across eras is difficult due to evolving rules, equipment, technology, and social contexts, making truly level playing fields impossible.
- Despite inherent difficulties, our 'GOAT' obsession often diminishes past legends, leading to "empty comparison" that "depletes sport."
- Instead of comparing, we should marvel at sport's journey, acknowledging past champions who paved the way for future generations.
AI generated
The result is inconceivable, but the referee is clear. Muhammad Ali has been out-boxed by a man 66 years older than him. On the radio, the commentator’s voice rises and the crowd buzzes.
Is this fact? No, just fantastic fabrication.
