SMRT Trains' losses soar to $155m on higher operating costs

Maintenance expenditure accounts for 71% of rail-fare revenue, up from 45% 3 years ago

The proportion of SMRT's spending on maintenance has been increasing steadily over the past four years, with the firm spending $425 million on rail maintenance-related costs in the last financial year.
An SMRT train near Admiralty MRT station.ST PHOTO: CHONG JUN LIANG

Losses are mounting for rail operator SMRT Trains on the back of higher operating expenses.

In the 12 months to end-March this year, losses hit $155 million - almost double from a year ago - the firm reported yesterday.

Spending on repairs and maintenance accounted for about 71 per cent of rail-fare revenue, up from just 45 per cent three years ago.

This means for every $1 collected, 71 cents went to maintenance-related expenditure. It includes maintenance staff costs, parts and materials costs, depreciation of rail assets and other rail maintenance-related operating expenses, the firm said.

SMRT added that its train business generated a lower revenue of $736.6 million in the last financial year, compared with $743.2 million the year before that.

With the way things are going, commuters can expect fares to eventually increase, experts have noted.

Transport Minister Khaw Boon Wan said in Parliament on July 8 that higher fares will be needed in the face of rising subsidies for public transport. He noted that rail operators were in the red, having increased expenditures in multi-year efforts to raise rail reliability.

Mr Khaw pointed out that the Government subsidises more than 30 per cent of public transport operations, and expects to spend $4.5 billion on operating subsidies over the next five years. This is on top of another $25 billion to be spent on building new lines.

Transport economist Walter Theseira told The Straits Times SMRT's increased losses were inevitable. "With mature rail systems, the only way your revenue really changes is if fare levels change," he said.

"When you have a system where maintenance costs are high because we need to make sure that the system is reliable... and revenue doesn't change, it should be no surprise that your losses go up," he added.

Dr Theseira also noted that unlike airlines, for example, that can add flights to boost passenger numbers, train operators are not able to easily increase ridership significantly to raise revenues over time.

"I think we need to ask ourselves what we actually want out of our transport systems and what we are willing to pay for that," he added. "You can have cheap or you can have good. But to get both at the same time, that is usually not possible."

In publishing its financial results, SMRT said it spent $425 million on rail maintenance-related costs in the last financial year.

The proportion of spending on maintenance has been increasing steadily over the past four years. In the 2015/2016 financial year, only 45 per cent of fare revenue was spent on maintenance expenditure.

The figure rose to 51 per cent the year after that and to 62 per cent in the 2017/2018 financial year.

Higher staff costs due to a higher headcount and increased electricity costs also weighed down its latest results, the train operator said.

At the group level, SMRT Corporation posted a net loss of $117.1 million for the year to end-March this year, up from $72.4 million a year ago.

The firm also announced that it will appoint Mr Tan Chian Khong as a new board director from today.

Mr Tan, who has 35 years of experience in the audit industry, will contribute through his expertise in managing financial and investment risks, SMRT said.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on August 01, 2019, with the headline 'SMRT Trains' losses soar to $155m on higher operating costs'. Subscribe