Letting children play alone outside could be a crime in the US

Sign up now: Get tips on how to help your child succeed

Mallerie Shirley was investigated by a county agency after allowing her son, six, to ride alone to a nearby playground in Atlanta.

Mallerie Shirley was investigated by a county agency after allowing her six-year-old son to ride his scooter alone to a nearby playground in Atlanta.

PHOTO: KENDRICK BRINSON/NYTIMES

Ian Frisch

  • Parents in the US face investigations or legal trouble for letting young children play or travel alone due to vague child-neglect laws and heightened fears about child safety.
  • Fear of abduction and helicopter parenting over decades have reduced children's independence, leading to increased anxiety and depression among kids.
  • New laws in 13 states and a proposed federal bill aim to protect children's rights to independence, but challenges and risks remain in balancing safety and autonomy.

AI generated

UNITED STATES – Mallerie Shirley knew something was wrong the second she saw her then six-year-old son walk through the front door. It was November 2025, and he had just returned from riding his scooter to a playground about 400m from their home in Atlanta.

She remembers how he looked: shoulders slouched, eyes cast downwards. She asked him what happened.

See more on