Lying to get their child into a top school

For Primary 1 registration, schools conduct a ballot when the number of applicants exceeds available places. Those who live nearer the school get priority in the ballot. Phase 2C is for those with no links to the school.
For Primary 1 registration, schools conduct a ballot when the number of applicants exceeds available places. Those who live nearer the school get priority in the ballot. Phase 2C is for those with no links to the school.ST FILE PHOTO

Some parents are prepared to risk a hefty fine or even a jail sentence to get their children into brand-name schools by faking their address. This hard-to-detect practice is not uncommon, market players say.

To get her older daughter into a brand-name primary school, a mother of two girls rented an apartment across the road.

The woman, who wants to be known only as Mrs Teo, moved into the apartment when her daughter was four, two years before Primary One registration 10 years ago. Her daughter got into the school in Bukit Timah, as did her other daughter later, who is two years younger.

"I was not the only one doing it. Which parent would not do that to secure their children's future," said Mrs Teo, 49. The girls went on to the affiliated secondary school.

Under a new rule introduced in 2015, children who gain priority admission to schools based on distance have to live at the address for at least 2½ years from the start of the registration exercise. Previously, no time period was set.

To some, Mrs Teo had gamed the system, even though she did not break the law. But others are prepared to risk a fine and a jail term by faking an address just to get their children into the school of their choice, property agents told The Sunday Times.

One agent, who did not want to be named, said he has had calls from at least six parents over the past three years, asking if property owners in certain estates could let them use the addresses, without their having to move there. Others said they have declined offers of between $1,000 and $2,000 by such desperate parents.

For Primary 1 registration, schools conduct a ballot when the number of applicants exceeds available places. Those who live nearer the school - usually within 1km - get priority in the ballot.

  • CHANGING AN ADDRESS

  • Step 1

    To change the residential address on your identity card, you need documentary proof of your new address. These include bills, such as those from the Housing Board or town council, or cable TV, utilities, telecom and insurance companies; bank statements;or a tenancy agreement for residence. The bills must be less than three months old.

    You can also use a bill, statement or letter from the Land Transport Authority, the Inland Revenue Authority Of Singapore or the Central Provident Fund Board. It must be less than a year old.

    If you do not have the required documentary proof, you must apply for a pre-notification letter online. The Immigration and Checkpoints Authority (ICA) will mail a letter to your new address within seven working days, which can be used as documentary evidence.

  • Step 2

    When you have the documentary proof, or received the pre-notification letter, you can visit a neighbourhood police post or police centre or the Citizen Services Centre at the ICA Building to get your address changed. Take your current identity card. If your documents are in order, the officer will make the necessary changes on it.

Last Monday, a 36-year-old mother was fined $5,000 for giving false information to a public servant to get her child into a popular school during Phase 2C of the 2015 Primary 1 registration exercise. Phase 2C is for those with no links to the school.

Her 39-year-old husband was fined $4,000 for giving a false contact address to a registration officer at the Serangoon Gardens Neighbourhood Police Post in 2014.

The couple had claimed their residential address was in Bishan, when they were still living in Serangoon Gardens. They secured their child a spot in the school in 2015, using a copy of their identity cards with the false contact address, which was within 1km of the school. The Education Ministry (MOE) had earlier reportedly said that action involving the child will be decided at a later stage.

Dr Timothy Chan, director of SIM Global Education's academic division, said some parents still define a "good school" based on its academic performance and its reputation. Professor S. Gopinathan, academic adviser at The Head Foundation, said: "Ours is a competitive education system.

"No one should break any laws, but high anxiety levels make people do foolish things."

National Institute of Education Associate Professor Jason Tan said MOE cannot stop such fraudulent behaviour from parents but can only trust them to be honest.

And when they cheat and lie, parents may not just be fined. In 2007, a lawyer was given 11 months in jail for forging and lying about his residential address in order to get his daughter into a reputable school in Bukit Timah.

 
 

Such cases are hard to detect, experts said. MOE said a case would be referred to the police when "there is reason to believe that a false address may have been used".

Pupils whose parents are found to have falsified their addresses to gain priority admission "would be transferred to another school with available vacancies", it cautioned.

But this forced transfer could cause the child to develop emotional problems, said Dr Jessie Chua, senior clinical psychologist at The Resilienz Clinic.

And psychiatrist Lim Boon Leng said that even if the child remained in the school, he "may live with a sense of guilt".

While some parents interviewed believe it is unfair to penalise the child, assistant sales manager Anthony Chua, 34, said a fine is merely a slap on the wrist for such parents.

"Their selfish actions might deprive other kids who genuinely live close to the school."

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Sunday Times on February 04, 2018, with the headline 'Lying to get their child into a top school'. Print Edition | Subscribe