Differing views provide rigour in policymaking, but S'pore must not let divergence lead to paralysis: DPM Heng

Deputy Prime Minister Heng Swee Keat and central bank chief Ravi Menon at the launch of the book The Singapore Synthesis: Innovation, Inclusion, Inspiration. ST PHOTO: FELINE LIM

SINGAPORE - A plurality of views adds to the rigour of policy formulation and implementation, but Singapore must not let a divergence of views lead to paralysis, Deputy Prime Minister Heng Swee Keat said on Tuesday (Aug 23).

He was speaking at the launch of the book The Singapore Synthesis: Innovation, Inclusion, Inspiration, a collection of four lectures that central bank chief Ravi Menon delivered in his capacity as the Institute of Policy Studies' ninth S R Nathan Fellow in July 2021.

The book also includes highlights of Mr Menon's dialogue with the audience.

DPM Heng, who is also Coordinating Minister for Economic Policies, said that while Singapore wants a diversity of views and to debate different perspectives rigorously, it also needs leaders with the vision and courage to decide on a course of action.

"Once a decision is taken, it is time to act collectively and decisively, with all hands on deck, and we must periodically review the choices made, to see whether we could do even better," said Mr Heng, adding that this is how things work in Singapore, and it has made the nation successful.

Mr Heng noted how the Monetary Authority of Singapore managing director's candour in his lecture series had drawn surprise from some, given his position in the establishment.

He reassured the audience at the event, held at the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, that Mr Menon had not gone rogue.

In his lectures, Mr Menon had brought up contentious suggestions such as increasing carbon taxes, raising wealth taxes and studying having a minimum wage.

But within the Government, issues are often extensively deliberated, Mr Heng said, adding that it is not just Mr Menon, but many others as well, who are contributing to the contestation of ideas.

Singapore must continue to harness this productive diversity of ideas, Mr Heng said.

He also stressed "the need to ensure that discourse grows the common space and not diminish it", referencing Mr Menon's lecture where he spoke about the celebration of diversity.

"There are difficult and deeply emotive issues that societies must grapple with, not just locally but globally.

"We must learn to handle these issues sensitively and with forbearance. Progress cannot be made by advocating loudly for a single viewpoint," said Mr Heng.

He cited the discourse on Section 377A of the Penal Code - a "longstanding and deep-seated issue, with strong views for and against a repeal".

Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, at the National Day Rally on Sunday, announced that Singapore will repeal the law criminalising sex between men, while amending the Constitution to protect the current definition of marriage from being challenged in court.

Remote video URL

This step towards "a new equilibrium" was taken after extensive consultation behind closed doors in a candid and constructive manner, Mr Heng said.

"A new balance would not be possible if people insist only on pushing across their views or venture into polemics," he said, adding that Singaporeans by and large cherish the harmony and common space they have.

"Even for difficult and evocative issues, parties have approached dialogue with respect, restraint and rationality," said Mr Heng.

He said that arriving at a new equilibrium on Section 377A will show that even for contentious issues, there can be room for accommodation.

"But we all need to do our part to carry out dialogue in a way that will move society forward and call out those whose actions undermine the harmony that we so treasure," said Mr Heng.

(From left) IPS director Janadas Devan, DPM Heng Swee Keat and MAS managing director Ravi Menon unveiling the book. ST PHOTO: FELINE LIM

Speaking after Mr Heng, Mr Menon said he wrote the lectures "out of a conviction that Singapore can do better".

"Uncertainty in the world around us need not obscure our own clarity of purpose. Our journey cannot be one of merely solving the problems that come our way; it must be guided by a vision of what we want to be and how we want to get there," he said, noting that this is also what the current Forward Singapore conversation is about.

On a similar note, Mr Heng expressed his hope that the book will inspire Singaporeans to step forward to shape the next chapter of the nation's history.

"Not just to contribute ideas, but to also put good ideas into action. In this way, we can continue to be an inspiring nation, an inclusive society and an innovative economy."

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.