Treatment order for man who drove against traffic

After Brandon Ng Hai Chong pleaded guilty to dangerous driving, he was assessed by the Institute of Mental Health to have major depressive disorder at the time of the offence.
After Brandon Ng Hai Chong pleaded guilty to dangerous driving, he was assessed by the Institute of Mental Health to have major depressive disorder at the time of the offence.ST PHOTO: WONG KWAI CHOW

Engineer gets two-year order after High Court allows appeal against four-week jail sentence

An engineer who drove against the flow of traffic on the Ayer Rajah Expressway (AYE) for about 2km was given a two-year mandatory treatment order (MTO) yesterday after the High Court allowed his appeal against his original sentence of four weeks' jail.

Brandon Ng Hai Chong, 31, is also banned from driving for five years.

In allowing Ng's appeal, Justice Aedit Abdullah said the district judge who imposed the jail term last year erred in finding that rehabilitation was not the dominant sentencing principle in the case.

Justice Aedit, however, noted that if injury or damage had been caused, an MTO would not be appropriate.

Ng was driving home in his BMW at about 1.25am on Jan 5, 2017, after a drinking session with friends.

He missed a left turn to the AYE in the direction of the city and entered the expressway heading towards Tuas instead.

Ng then made a U-turn and drove on the rightmost lane against the flow of traffic for two minutes, averaging a speed of 50kmh.

At least three vehicles had to switch lanes to avoid a collision.

When he was near the exit to his Clementi home, he turned on his hazard lights and flashed his high beam at oncoming traffic, causing at least four vehicles to avoid him.

Ng then made another U-turn to go with the flow of traffic, filtered left and headed home.

Three motorists called the police to report the incident.

 
 

After he pleaded guilty to dangerous driving, he was assessed by the Institute of Mental Health (IMH) to be suffering from major depressive disorder at the time of the offence.

The IMH psychiatrist recommended a two-year MTO.

However, Ng was sentenced to four weeks' jail and given a five-year driving ban. The district judge who imposed the sentence said that while Ng was recommended for an MTO, his depression did not affect his impulsivity and that deterrence was still the dominant sentencing consideration.

Ng, who was represented by Mr Luke Lee, then appealed to the High Court. Mr Lee argued that the district judge had failed to address why he steered clear from the psychiatrist's opinion that there was a contributory link between his psychiatric condition and his offending behaviour.

Rehabilitation should be the dominant principle, given that Ng's depression was treatable, he said.

Deputy Public Prosecutor Gabriel Choong argued that deterrence was necessary as public safety was involved and outweighed the principle of rehabilitation.

The DPP argued that Ng consciously drove in the way he did to reach the exit closest to his home.

But Justice Aedit said the district judge had failed to fully assess Ng's mental condition in context and inadvertently downplayed his true rehabilitative potential. Treatment would also hopefully prevent future incidents, said the judge.

In allowing Ng's appeal, Justice Aedit Abdullah said the district judge who imposed the jail term last year erred in finding that rehabilitation was not the dominant sentencing principle in the case.

The judge, however, noted that if injury or damage had been caused, an MTO would not be appropriate.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on April 27, 2019, with the headline 'Treatment order for man who drove against traffic'. Print Edition | Subscribe