A woman who slapped her maid so hard that she suffered a temporary loss of hearing was sentenced to seven months' jail yesterday.
Gayathri Iyer, 51, was convicted in February following a trial of two counts of abusing her maid, Myanmar national Thang Khaw Lam, 30.
She suffered hearing loss in her left ear for at least a month. She later recovered from her injuries and was found to have normal hearing.
Ms Thang Khaw Lam started working for Gayathri's family in June 2017 at the Pebble Bay condominium in Tanjong Rhu Road.
On Oct 27 that year, the housewife hit the maid's shoulder after the domestic worker used the word "mah" when talking to her.
Using a mobile phone, Ms Thang Khaw Lam took photographs of the bruises, which were at the top of her shoulder and extended slightly to her back.
The second incident happened on Dec 7 that year, at about 5.40am, when Gayathri slapped her for failing to wake her son who was then serving national service.
Ms Thang Khaw Lam was doing the laundry then.
Gayathri slapped the maid twice on her left ear and once on her right. The maid said she could not hear anything in her left ear for the whole day.
About five days after the incident, Ms Thang Khaw Lam fled from Gayathri's home and told the police about her ordeal.
She recovered from her injuries by Sept 5, 2018.
District Judge Tan Jen Tse acquitted Gayathri of two other assault charges involving the maid, finding the domestic worker's evidence in these instances not unusually convincing.
Yesterday, Deputy Public Prosecutor Tan Ee Kuan urged the court to jail the accused for nine months, saying there was an oppressive relationship between the maid and her employer.
Gayathri's lawyer Kalidass Murugaiyan asked the court for a sentence of nine weeks, saying his client used to be a counsellor at Changi Prison, and had pledged to donate all of her organs despite being a Hindu.
District Judge Tan, in sentencing Gayathri to seven months' jail, said the prosecution had not proven beyond reasonable doubt that there was a sustained pattern of abuse.
And the judge was not able to find that the victim had suffered psychological harm.
He also ordered Gayathri to make compensation of about $5,330 to the maid.
Gayathri is appealing against the sentence, and is out on $15,000 bail.
For each count of assaulting a maid, she could have been jailed for up to three years and fined up to $7,500.