Couple found guilty of abusing second maid sentenced to jail

Husband and wife repeatedly abused Myanmar maid, including by caning her and ordering her to eat own vomit

Chia Yun Ling (left) and Tay Wee Kiat, who were convicted in 2017 of abusing their Indonesian maid, were yesterday sentenced to prison over the abuse of their other maid from Myanmar.
Chia Yun Ling (left) and Tay Wee Kiat, who were convicted in 2017 of abusing their Indonesian maid, were yesterday sentenced to prison over the abuse of their other maid from Myanmar.ST PHOTOS: KEVIN LIM

A married couple repeatedly abused their maid, who was caned, kicked and force-fed a mixture of rice and sugar before being ordered to eat her own vomit when she threw up.

Myanmar national Moe Moe Than, 32, was also forced to perform her chores clad in only her bra and shorts on one occasion. She was also told that an assassin would be hired to kill her family members back home.

Yesterday, former senior sales manager Chia Yun Ling, 43, was sentenced to three years and 11 months in jail and fined $4,000. She was also ordered to pay the maid $6,500 in compensation.

District Judge Olivia Low sentenced her husband, Tay Wee Kiat, 41, who used to work as a regional IT manager, to two years in jail and ordered him to pay compensation of $3,000.

After a 31-day trial, the judge convicted the couple on March 4 of maid abuse.

Chia was convicted of eight assault charges and one count of using abusive words towards the maid. The judge also found the mother-of-three guilty of six offences under the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act.

Judge Low found Tay guilty of six assault charges. The Myanmar national started working at the couple's Yishun home on Jan 8, 2012.

Yesterday, Judge Low noted that Chia had restricted Ms Moe Moe Than's toilet usage to three times a day. She added: "The deprivation of a basic human right to manage one's bodily functions strikes at the core of one's dignity... and constituted ill treatment."

Chia had also ordered the maid to strip from the waist down before caning the latter's bare buttocks.

Tay abused Ms Moe Moe Than through acts such as caning and kicking her while she was in a "push-up position". He also used a broomstick and metal clothing hook to hit her.

The offences came to light when Ms Moe Moe Than returned to Yangon on Nov 12, 2012, and told her Myanmar agent about her plight.

Singapore's Ministry of Manpower was later alerted, and it arranged for her to return here about a month later. The maid later told Judge Low about her ordeal.

The judge convicted the couple after the trial, but she also acquitted them of two charges each.

Chia had been acquitted of failing to ensure that all outstanding salaries due to Ms Moe Moe Than had been paid before her repatriation. Tay, on the other hand, had been acquitted of instructing their other maid, Ms Fitriyah, 34, to hit the Myanmar national.

Yesterday, Deputy Public Prosecutor Kumaresan Gohulabalan said the prosecution will be appealing against the acquittals.

Defence lawyer Wee Pan Lee told the court that his clients have not decided on whether to appeal against Judge Low's decisions.

The couple have been released on bail of $15,000 each and if they decide not to appeal, they will surrender themselves at the State Courts on March 27 to begin serving their sentences.

Prior to the trial involving Ms Moe Moe Than, the couple had been taken to court for abusing Ms Fitriyah, who goes by only one name.

In March 2017, District Judge Shaiffudin Saruwan sentenced Tay to two years and four months in jail for abusing the Indonesian maid. Chia was given a two-month jail term for assaulting her.

Both the prosecution and the defence later appealed against Judge Shaiffudin's decisions.

Following their appeals in the High Court last March, Tay's jail term was increased to three years and seven months, while Chia's sentence remained at two months.

The couple remained free until the second trial, which concerned the abuse of Ms Moe Moe Than.

With an upcoming appeal involving Ms Moe Moe Than's case, the High Court will decide in the future how the sentences for the cases involving both maids will be served.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on March 19, 2019, with the headline 'Couple found guilty of abusing second maid sentenced to jail'. Subscribe