15 years' jail for maid who killed elderly employer by stabbing her in the throat

Indonesian maid Minah (above) was sentenced to 15 years' jail after she pleaded guilty to a charge of culpable homicide for killing Madam Tay Quee Lang.
Indonesian maid Minah (above) was sentenced to 15 years' jail after she pleaded guilty to a charge of culpable homicide for killing Madam Tay Quee Lang.PHOTO: ST FILE
Indonesian maid Minah (centre) seen leaving the unit at Tampines Street 22 with police officers, on Feb 13, 2017, to assist in investigations.
Indonesian maid Minah (centre) seen leaving the unit at Tampines Street 22 with police officers, on Feb 13, 2017, to assist in investigations. ST PHOTO: ARIFFIN JAMAR

SINGAPORE - One month into her job, a domestic worker became so incensed by her elderly employer nagging at her for taking a long time to eat that she plunged a knife into her neck.

When questioned by police, the 38-year-old Indonesian maid, Minah, lied that 77-year-old Madam Tay Quee Lang had committed suicide.

Minah was sentenced to 15 years' jail on Monday (April 23) after she pleaded guilty to a charge of culpable homicide for killing Madam Tay in her Tampines Street 22 flat on Feb 13 last year .

In sentencing, Judicial Commissioner Audrey Lim agreed with prosecutors, who sought a deterrent jail term of at least 15 years for Minah's calculated acts against a defenceless victim.

The judge said the maid's response to the nagging was "clearly disproportionate and unwarranted". "It's not a case where the deceased had used any form of violence or used any threat against you," she said.

As soon as sentence was passed, two of Madam Tay's family members in the public gallery started sobbing, while another pumped his fist and uttered "yes".

After court was adjourned, the family members shouted "Satan", "die in prison" and "go to hell" as Minah was led away by guards. They declined to speak to reporters.

The High Court heard that Minah started working for Madam Tay and her husband, Mr Tan Hee Seng, 78, both retirees, in January last year.

 

Mr Tan had employed the maid to care for Madam Tay, who needed a walking stick and assistance to move around.

By all accounts, apart from one incident in which the maid shouted at Mr Tan when he told her not to waste water, she got along well with her employers.

On Feb 13, Mr Tan left the flat for a medical appointment after feeding Madam Tay her lunch and helping her back to her rattan chair in the living room.

According to Minah, while she was having her lunch in the kitchen, Madam Tay repeatedly called out to her. Madam Tay scolded her for taking a long time to eat because she was using her mobile phone and they ended up shouting at each other.

To stop Madam Tay from talking, the maid took a kitchen knife with a 22 cm-long blade, and walked towards her. When Madam Tay saw the knife, she carried on complaining and told the maid that she was not afraid of her, the court heard.

When Minah held the edge of the knife near Madam Tay's throat, the elderly woman tried to push the knife away. But the maid thrust the knife into Madam Tay's neck, leaving her gasping for air.

The maid then washed Madam Tay's blood off her fingernails and phoned her employer's daughter.

A neighbour, who heard a female voice crying, saw Minah pacing around the living room, murmuring "tolong tolong" - a plea for help. He called the police when he saw Madam Tay with a knife lodged in her throat.

An autopsy found that Madam Tay bled to death from the single stab wound, which was so deep that it entered the apex of her left lung.

On Monday, Deputy Public Prosecutor Bhajanvir Singh sought a deterrent sentence for the "senseless and unwarranted" killing that arose from a minor quarrel. He argued that acts of physical violence by domestic workers against employers must be condemned.

Minah's lawyer, Mr Nasser Ismail, asked for 12 to 15 years, saying that she was remorseful and would like to apologise to Madam Tay's family.