Forum: Time to take animal abuse cases more seriously
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox
The recent reports of cat deaths in Yishun and Punggol are disturbing (‘What kind of person will do this?’: Shanmugam condemns abuse, killing of Yishun community cat, May 9; and NParks investigating another brutal cat death – this time in Punggol, May 13).
These are not isolated cases. The Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals received 961 reports of animal cruelty and poor welfare in 2024 – the highest in over a decade, with cats making up the majority (Animal cruelty and neglect cases in S’pore hit 12-year high; SPCA calls for stronger protection, Jan 7).
The fact that Law and Home Affairs Minister K. Shanmugam has weighed in is heartening, but concern alone is not enough. We must address this issue with greater seriousness in both prevention and enforcement.
Animal cruelty is more than a moral failing – it is a red flag. Studies show that those who abuse animals in childhood are more likely to commit violent crimes later in life.
Beyond individual acts, widespread cruelty reflects the psychological health of a community. Even for bystanders, such cruelty can take a toll on mental well-being, causing feelings of sadness, guilt and helplessness.
Strong penalties are available under Singapore law – the Animals and Birds Act allows for up to 18 months’ jail and fines of $15,000 for a first offence. But maximum sentences have never been imposed. In one of the worst neglect cases, involving 43 starved cats, the offender was sentenced to just 20 days in jail. Prosecution rates are also low – only 4 per cent of 1,200 yearly animal cruelty cases result in any enforcement action.
Offenders are often banned from owning pets for just 12 months, and there are no mandatory mental health checks or follow-ups to prevent repeat offences.
Singapore is known for its firm approach to crime. The same resolve should be applied to protecting defenceless animals.
Legalising cats in HDB flats was a welcome step. Now, let’s take the next step – by strengthening enforcement, increasing prosecutions and ensuring real deterrence. This is the least we can do to raise the mark of a society that takes compassion seriously.
Nigel Yong Kok Chun
