Can we make pop culture great again?

Wicked and Gladiator II are signs that the relationship between art and commerce isn’t working as it should.

Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox

Side-by-side posters for historical Roman epic Gladiator II and musical movie Wicked on their opening day at the AMC Lincoln Square 13 theatre in Manhattan on Nov 22.

Side-by-side posters for historical Roman epic Gladiator II and musical movie Wicked on their opening day at the AMC Lincoln Square 13 theatre in Manhattan on Nov 22.

PHOTO: NYTIMES

Ross Douthat

When the movies Wicked and Gladiator II debuted together late last month, there was a painful attempt to call their shared box office success “Glicked” – a reference to the portmanteau of “Barbenheimer” that described the joint cultural triumph of Barbie and Oppenheimer in the summer of 2023.

It was painful because the Barbenheimer phenomenon was a genuine old-fashioned Hollywood success story: Two unusual and vivid and original stories (based, yes, on real history and a famous doll, but no less creative for all that) from directors working near the peak of their powers that managed to be culturally relevant and open for interpretive debate.

See more on