Don't blame singer Lu Han for Shanghai Fortress' box-office flop, angry fans tell director

Shanghai Fortress stars (from far left) Godfrey Gao, Lu Han and Shu Qi.
Shanghai Fortress stars (from far left) Godfrey Gao, Lu Han and Shu Qi.PHOTO: GODFREY GAO / INSTAGRAM

At first, the director of Shanghai Fortress took the blame when the movie, touted to follow in the footsteps of successful sci-fi film The Wandering Earth, failed to take off at the box office.

In a post, Teng Huatao said he was fine with criticism of his work in the past but he was now despondent that the backlash had widened to claims that he had brought shame to the country.

He noted that netizens were accusing him of closing the door to Chinese sci-fi after The Wandering Earth had forged a path forward for the genre.

Saying that he was very sad, he added that "as director, I have ultimate responsibility, and I am very sorry".

Shanghai Fortress, which is based on a novel by Jiang Nan, tracks the efforts to ward off alien invaders, with Shanghai being the last human stronghold.

Now, as Shanghai Fortress disappears from the box-office radar, with the movie even failing to make the top 10 list on Wednesday (Aug 22) after it opened on Aug 9, Teng has drawn further criticism beyond the initial brickbats over the poor special effects and incoherent plot.

This time, fans of Lu Han, who stars in the movie, which cost an estimated US$57 million (S$79 million) to make, are upset that Teng has shifted some of the blame to the singer.

According to the 38jiejie portal, Teng said in an interview that he had made a mistake in casting Lu in the role of a commander that was not "suitable" for him, given that Lu is a pop idol.


Lu's fans, upset over the comments, said it was unprofessional for Teng - who had overall control of the movie - not to back his actors.

They added that it was not entirely Lu's fault if he was paired with an older actress - Shu Qi, 43 - and that the two did not generate much chemistry on screen.

Some blasted Teng for not examining other aspects of his film-making for the poor box-office response but looking for a convenient scapegoat instead.

Amid the finger-pointing, more level-headed pundits are asking for a stocktake.

A commentator on wrote: "It's not the end of the world... (Shanghai Fortress' flop) is a great lesson to learn. The difficulties facing Chinese sci-fi film-making include lack of genuine talent, original stories, industry chains, venture funds, vision and imagination.

"These need to be further explored and nurtured over a long journey."