Why I changed my investment portfolio

I recently did what most financial advice forbids: I stuck my hand in my retirement portfolio and backed out of some stocks.

Earlier this month, I stared at my long-term portfolio, got spooked by the 81 per cent that sat in equities and dialled that figure back to a more moderate 60 per cent. I also tripled the fixed income portion of my portfolio to 27 per cent.

I'd been pretty aggressive since I started investing in my early 20s and benefited from the hefty exposure to stocks. In just the past two years, my portfolio has been up 28 per cent.

So, why the change in direction? Why not just "stay the course", as many financial experts (myself included) encourage us to do, especially in these uncertain times?

I'm concerned about the fundamentals of our economy. I'm worried about if and how the job market can rebound any time soon, and I'm not as bullish on long-term stock returns.

Continuously exposing my nest egg to all this risk now feels overzealous. Although the stock market appears to suggest we're headed for a robust recovery, I'm not buying it.

More relevant, I turned 40 this year and am hoping to begin drawing down on this portfolio starting at 60. That gives me a solid 20 more years to hit my savings target.

I know that's probably enough time to recover from this recession.

I am the breadwinner in our marriage, with my earnings accounting for about 80 per cent of household income. My business largely helps to support our family of four and the house in the suburbs we just purchased. My plate's becoming increasingly full, and I don't have as much room now for a highly unpredictable, volatile investment portfolio.

It felt like a betrayal, going against the "do nothing" advice that has become the industry standard. Still, I'm confident it was the right move for me.

And the certified financial planners I spoke to along the way, while not exactly high-fiving my decision, admit that I'm not misguided.

"The current events triggered you to reassess, but, really, this is something you should do annually or whenever there's a major life event such as having children, (making a) career change or retirement," said Ms Angela Moore, founder of Modern Money Advisor, a financial planning firm based in Miami, Florida.

Constantly worrying about your investment portfolio is a valid sign that you may be taking on too much risk, the experts agreed.

"The best balance between equities and fixed income provides us the possibility of growing our funds to meet our goals, but also lets us sleep at night," market veteran Linda Davis Taylor said.

And that's just it. I couldn't sleep. Lying in bed, unable to stop thinking about what ifs.

What if the looming fiscal cliff leads to a second Great Depression? What if a cure for Covid is years away, if it ever comes at all?

What if our family depletes our more than one year's worth of emergency savings in the said Depression, with still no end in sight to this madness?

All these questions warranted a closer look at the numbers.

Making money moves based on pure adrenaline is never wise, and I was emotionally charged. So I asked, would I be willing to commit to this new allocation for the next, say, 10 years and not be tempted to revert on a whim? I rationalised, yes.

And what about hitting my target savings goal? A more conservative portfolio may no longer get me to where I want to be in the same time horizon. To offset this potentially slower growth, I made a personal commitment to invest more of my income. This was something all the planners cheered.

"You have no control over what the market does, no matter what your allocation is," says Ms Moore. "The savings part is the only part you can control."

So, my parting advice for anyone considering a shift in their portfolio is to think of your investments as just one aspect of your overall financial solvency. If you're going to take a smaller position in stocks, what else in your financial life may need to be adjusted to offset this potentially smaller nest egg? Do you need to save more in an emergency account? Delay retirement? Take out a long-term disability policy?

As financial adviser Anjali Jariwala puts it: "If you're revisiting asset allocation, then you should just revisit everything on your financial checklist, all the things that are there to protect your income and assets. Make sure you're buttoned up."


  • The writer is a financial journalist, author and host of the So Money podcast.

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Sunday Times on August 16, 2020, with the headline Why I changed my investment portfolio. Subscribe