Nervy markets await outcome for opaque bond tied to Evergrande

China Evergrande Group, the world's most indebted developer, may be facing its next big debt test, underscoring the broader risks of opaque obligations in credit markets already on edge.
China Evergrande Group, the world's most indebted developer, may be facing its next big debt test, underscoring the broader risks of opaque obligations in credit markets already on edge.PHOTO: EPA-EFE

HONG KONG (BLOOMBERG) - China Evergrande Group has already fallen behind on payments to banks, suppliers and holders of onshore investment products, and has not given any indication that it paid two recent dollar bond coupons.

Now, the world's most indebted developer may be facing its next big debt test, underscoring the broader risks of opaque obligations in credit markets already on edge.

People familiar with the matter have said that a dollar note maturing on Oct 3 issued at an initial amount of US$260 million (S$353 million) by an entity called Jumbo Fortune Enterprises is guaranteed by Evergrande. As the maturity date falls on a Sunday, the effective due date is Monday (Oct 4).

The issuer is a joint venture whose owners include Hengda Real Estate, Evergrande's main onshore unit. Non-payment of the bond principal would constitute a default as the note has no grace period, although five business days would be allowed if failure to pay is down to administrative and technical errors, according to the people.

Details of the guarantees were not broadly known as the note prospectus is not publicly available and the deal was not listed on exchanges. Any failure to pay Jumbo Fortune's note may also pose a risk of cross-default for Evergrande's other bonds, according to Bloomberg Intelligence analyst Daniel Fan.

Creditors of the Jumbo Fortune note could potentially ask the trustee to declare a formal default if they achieve a minimum threshold of investors, and that could trigger holders of other dollar bonds to do the same, he said.

Uncertainly over the full extent of Evergrande's debt load, beyond its more than US$300 billion reported in liabilities, has plagued investors since a liquidity crisis at the firm stoked fears of a collapse that could trigger financial and economic contagion. The authorities, ranging from Federal Reserve officials to Hong Kong's central bank, are looking into just how exposed financial institutions are to the crisis.

Ms Becky Liu, Standard Chartered Bank's head of China macro strategy, expects Evergrande to have more structured products such as guaranteed bonds, similar to the Jumbo Fortune note, with offshore dollar bonds making up just 6 per cent of the firm's total reported liabilities.

Law firm White & Case is advising various investors with regards to Jumbo Fortune, a spokesman for the firm said.

There was no response from Evergrande to a request for comment about its interest payments or debt guarantees.

Debt crises historically have a way of worsening when obligations that had flown under the radar suddenly start showing up on screen.

In the 2007-2008 global financial crisis, opaque mortgage-backed securities whose risks were hard to quantify played a major role. More recently in China, credit markets have at times been shaken by uncertainty about debt guarantees and intertwined obligations that were excluded from balance sheets.

Cross-guarantees have been a problem for China over the past decade with the rise of shadow banking, said Mr Andrew Collier, managing director of Orient Capital Research in Hong Kong.

"There is little ability to find out the size of the problem until there is a debt blow-up and creditors worry about not getting paid," he added.

Some Evergrande dollar securities have repayment acceleration provisions that stipulate that any indebtedness reaching US$20 million could constitute an event of default, according to the offering memorandum of notes seen by Bloomberg.

Creditors are not able to take legal action until bonds are formally declared to be in default. While creditors have the option of filing lawsuits in an offshore court to enforce Evergrande's payment obligations, "practically, bond holders may enter into some informal standstill and negotiate with the issuer", said Bloomberg Intelligence's Mr Fan.

The embattled developer is not the only firm adding to its debt piles with bonds that are not listed on exchanges and may lack much publicly available information.

Private placements are popular among China's real estate firms as these securities can be simpler to arrange than public deals - they are typically sold to a small group of investors, with no expectations about the size and more room to negotiate on pricing.

Evergrande is likely to have more securities of a similar kind and "if holders don't tell, no one will know of such debts' existence", said senior Asia credit strategist Ting Meng at ANZ Banking Group.