US report says India acts minimally, Pakistan rarely acts against rights abuses
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox
Indian PM Narendra Modi denies discrimination and says his policies, such as food subsidy programmes and electrification drives, benefit everyone.
PHOTO: REUTERS
Follow topic:
WASHINGTON – The US government noted abuses in India and Pakistan in a shortened human rights report released on Aug 12 that said India “took minimal credible steps” to combat the abuses while Pakistan “rarely took credible steps”.
The Trump administration scaled back the annual US government report on human rights worldwide, dramatically softening criticism of some allies and countries that have been US President Donald Trump’s partners.
The US State Department human rights documentation for India and Pakistan was also much shorter and scaled back for 2025.
India has been an important US partner in recent years in Washington’s effort to counter China’s rise, although relations have been tense over Mr Trump’s imposition of a 50 per cent tariff
Pakistan is a non-Nato US ally.
About India, the report said: “The government took minimal credible steps or action to identify and punish officials who committed human rights abuses.”
On Pakistan, it added: “The government rarely took credible steps to identify and punish officials who committed human rights abuses.”
Indian and Pakistani embassies in Washington had no immediate comment on the report released on Aug 12, which documented instances in 2024.
Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch fault Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government for its treatment of minorities.
They point to rising hate speeches, a religion-based citizenship law the UN calls “fundamentally discriminatory”, anti-conversion legislation that challenges freedom of belief, the 2019 removal of Muslim-majority Kashmir’s special status, and the demolition of properties owned by Muslims.
Mr Modi denies discrimination and says his policies, such as food subsidy programmes and electrification drives, benefit everyone.
In Pakistan, Amnesty International says the government authorities fail to protect minorities, including Christians, and use “excessive and unnecessary force” against civil society voices and protesters.
In particular, rights groups, the UN, and Western governments raised concerns over the 2024 Pakistani elections.
A UN working group said in 2024 that former Pakistani prime minister Imran Khan’s detention
Islamabad says its elections were fair and dismisses allegations of rigging and foul play.
Washington and New Delhi have not reached a trade deal, while the United States has reached an agreement in recent weeks with Pakistan.
Mr Trump angered India by taking credit for an India-Pakistan ceasefire
India says New Delhi and Islamabad should resolve their ties directly without outside involvement. REUTERS
