Editorial Notes

Taliban's skewed priorities: Dawn

The paper says the Taliban government has more serious issues at hand to tackle than police the behaviour of women.

A Taliban fighter stands guard at the market in Kabul, Afghanistan, on Oct 24, 2021.
A Taliban fighter stands guard at the market in Kabul, Afghanistan, on Oct 24, 2021.PHOTO: REUTERS

ISLAMABAD (DAWN/ASIA NEWS NETWORK) - Clearly, the Afghan Taliban are more worried about women journalists appearing on TV without wearing the "Islamic hijab" in line with "Islamic or Afghani" values than the unfolding humanitarian catastrophe under their watch.

Just as the UN was issuing urgent appeals to the international community to come to the rescue of millions of hapless Afghans facing hunger, the Taliban's Ministry for the Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice issued "religious guidelines" calling on Afghanistan's television channels to stop showing dramas and soap operas featuring women actors.

It is not immediately clear when, or if, these guidelines will be applied, though a Taliban official said they were not rules, indicating that they might not be implemented. It is difficult to take the Taliban at their word given their past history of enforcing their hard-line interpretation of the Sharia, and literally banishing women from the public space.

The new guidelines also fly in the face of the claims of the new rulers and their supporters that Taliban 2.0 are moderate and different from the older version of late 1996 and that they would be more accommodating towards women and minorities now.

True, the Taliban have allowed domestic and international media to operate in Afghanistan, albeit with some restrictions. But they have yet to live up to their pledges to the international community to respect human rights and form a broad-based government that includes women in its ranks.

There was some optimism following the Troika Plus meeting in Islamabad this month that the Taliban were listening to international concerns regarding key human rights issues; the world at large was also keen to find a way to help millions of Afghans in the country. Surely, the guidelines have not helped in improving the world's perception of the hard-line rulers.

The Taliban leadership, that previously shied away from being photographed, now love to be on camera giving interviews, and some of them to women journalists. They must know that they are ruling a new Afghanistan with a vibrant and resilient media and an active, educated urban youth on social media. They can neither be wished away nor pushed away from public discourse or denied entertainment within the legitimate confines of Afghan social values.

They must also realise that they have far more serious issues at hand to tackle. Just on Monday, the UN pushed for more urgent action to prop up Afghanistan's banks, warning that the country's financial system could collapse within months due to the liquidity crunch, low cash deposits and people's inability to repay their loans.

"Afghanistan's financial and bank payment systems are in disarray. The bank-run problem must be resolved quickly," the UN Development Programme (UNDP) said in a report. Stressing that the situation was dire, the report said the world needed to think "outside the box" to save the system. It is a warning that must be heeded.

  • The paper is a member of The Straits Times media partner Asia News Network, an alliance of 24 news media organisations.