PAS delegate warns Malaysia could become 'second Singapore' if Malay rights sidelined

Parti Islam SeMalaysia flags in Johor Baru in April 2018, ahead of Malaysia's 14th general election.
Parti Islam SeMalaysia flags in Johor Baru in April 2018, ahead of Malaysia's 14th general election.ST PHOTO: TIMOTHY DAVID

KUANTAN - The Malay community's special rights were raised at Parti Islam SeMalaysia's (PAS) annual assembly on Saturday (June 22), with a delegate warning that Malaysia could become a "second Singapore" if these rights were sidelined under the Pakatan Harapan (PH) government.

Selangor PAS election director Roslan Shahir Mohamad Shahir pointed the finger at the Chinese-dominated Democratic Action Party (DAP), one of the four member parties of PH, saying it was a "reincarnation" of the People's Action Party (PAP) which was formerly led by Singapore's late prime minister Lee Kuan Yew.

Mr Roslan said the DAP posed a threat to Malay Muslims, as it could take away the Malays' special rights as well as separate religion from the state.

According to Mr Roslan, Mr Lee had told the Malaysian Parliament in May 1965 that, "We cannot agree to anything but a Malaysian Malaysia. We are prepared to play in accordance with the rules too: wait 5 years, 10 years, 15 years but the ideas we represent must come true."

Singapore separated from Malaysia to become an independent state in August 1965, after deep political and economic differences between their ruling parties. Ethnic Chinese represent the majority community in Singapore, making up 74 per cent of the resident population while Malays comprise 14 per cent.

Mr Roslan warned that unless PAS and Umno, which are the two biggest Malay-Muslim opposition parties, cooperate, Malays could lose their special rights under Malaysia's affirmative action policy.

"We face a big threat, if we are careless, we will see our dignity, race and country compromised. It is not impossible for us to become a second Singapore," said Mr Roslan.

Professor James Chin, director of the Asia Institute, University of Tasmania, told The Straits Times that the accusations against DAP are not new and were used in the run-up to last May's polls.

The indirect message from PAS, he said, is that Malays in Singapore are sidelined by PAP, and DAP will do the same thing to Malays in Malaysia, he said.

"They used the same narrative during elections. Malays are discriminated by DAP, and DAP controls the PH government. PAS and Umno want to use this narrative for the next general election. PAS is playing racial politics to the hilt," he said.


Former ruling party Umno entered into a political alliance with PAS after it was trounced at the general election in May 2018. Umno and the Barisan Nasional coalition it leads has won three by-elections this year, after PAS agreed to stay out of the races and not split the Malay vote.

The two parties have tapped fears within the Malay community, who make up some 60 per cent of the 32 million population, that DAP is calling the shots in the PH administration of Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad, and that Malay and Muslim issues are being sidelined.

This is despite the DAP only having 42 MPs in the 222-seat Parliament, while its Malay-led partners Parti Keadilan Rakyat, Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia and Parti Amanah Negara have 87 MPs in total.

Additionally, 117 out of the 222 parliamentary seats are Malay-majority wards.

The one million-strong PAS currently controls the state legislatures of Kelantan and Terengganu and has 18 MPs in Parliament. Umno-led Barisan Nasional controls the state assemblies of Pahang and Perlis, and has 40 MPs in total.

While the PAS-Umno collaboration has proved fruitful so far, not all PAS members welcome the idea of teaming up with former foe Umno. 

Mr Ahmad Yahya, a delegate from Kedah warned that dissatisfied members could leave and form a new party. “If we fail to explain to our party members (about the cooperation with Umno), then we will have challenges,” he said in his speech at the assembly on Saturday. 

PAS leaders however endorsed the pact on Saturday evening, with the powerful cleric wing giving the green light for the party to form “unity governments” with Umno in the four states they control.