Why North Korea’s Kim had little need for photo-op with Trump

GYEONGJU, South Korea - US President Donald Trump may have hoped for an impromptu talk with his old friend Kim Jong Un during a recent trip to Asia, but analysts say the increasingly emboldened North Korean leader had few good reasons to join the photo-op.

Mr Trump sent

repeated overtures to Mr Kim

during his barnstorming tour of Asia, saying he was “100 per cent” open to a meeting and even bucking decades of US policy by conceding that North Korea was “sort of a nuclear power”.

But Pyongyang kept mum on the invitation, instead

firing off missiles

and sending its foreign minister to Russia and Belarus, with whom it has deepened ties in recent years.

“The brutal reality is that Kim Jong Un had no incentive to participate,” said Dr Seong-Hyon Lee, a visiting scholar at the Harvard University Asia Centre.

“It was a fundamental miscalculation by Washington to believe he would,” said Dr Lee.

Mr Trump’s repeated overtures instead represented a “victory” for the North Korean leader – offering him and his nuclear programme a massive degree of credibility, Dr Lee said.

“President Trump gave Kim a massive, unearned concession,” he explained.

The pair – who Mr Trump once famously declared were “in love” – last met in 2019 at

Panmunjom in the Demilitarised Zone (DMZ)

separating the two Koreas after the US leader extended an invitation to Mr Kim on Twitter.

That overture to Pyongyang spearheaded by Mr Trump eventually collapsed over the scope of denuclearisation of the North and sanctions relief.

Since then, North Korea has declared itself an “irreversible” nuclear state and forged close links to Russia, sending troops to support Moscow in its war on Ukraine.

Mr Kim is now in a “pretty sweet spot”, Ms Soo Kim, a former CIA analyst, told AFP.

“Russia’s backing is probably one of the most decisive factors strengthening and cementing North Korea’s strategic hand these days,” she said.

“He maintains the upper hand, which makes it easier for him to pass on Trump’s invitation,” Ms Soo Kim told AFP.

Heading home from South Korea and a

meeting with Chinese leader Xi Jinping

, Mr Trump said he had been too “busy” to meet Mr Kim, though he added he could return.

The scene stood in stark contrast to 2019, when denuclearisation and sanctions relief talks in Hanoi, Vietnam,

collapsed in dramatic fashion

– leaving Mr Kim to endure a long train journey back to Pyongyang with no deal in hand.

Dr Vladimir Tikhonov, Korean Studies professor at the University of Oslo, told AFP that experience had left Pyongyang sore.

“They don’t want to venture forward too rushingly,” he said.

Instead, Dr Tikhonov said, Pyongyang may be holding out for more specific proposals from Mr Trump, including formal diplomatic recognition and sanctions relief without denuclearisation.

Friends like these

And closer alliances elsewhere mean Mr Kim has little reason to chase approval from Washington.

This week, Pyongyang’s headed to Moscow, where she and Russian President Vladimir Putin agreed to strengthen bilateral ties.

Analysts say North Korea is receiving extensive financial aid, military technology, and food and energy assistance from Russia.

That has allowed it to sidestep tough international sanctions imposed over its nuclear and missile programmes that were once a crucial bargaining chip for the United States.

Freeflowing trade with China – which soared to its highest level in nearly six years in September, according to analysts – has also helped ease Pyongyang’s economic isolation.

In September,

Mr Kim appeared alongside China’s Xi Jinping

and Russia’s Vladimir Putin at an elaborate military parade in Beijing – a striking display of his new, elevated status in global politics.

Mr Kim now has “no reason to trade this new, high-status quo for a photo-op” with Mr Trump, said Harvard’s Dr Lee.

Mr Kim has a “strategic lifeline from Russia and China, and he sees the US-China competition as a long-term guarantee of his own manoeuvrability.”

The North Korean leader is now operating from a “position of strength”. AFP