HK scientists fight to save city-defining fragrant incense trees

HONG KONG – Geneticist Zhang Huarong walks through a forest near his Hong Kong research lab, gesturing towards a rotting stump of an incense tree that is one of over a dozen illegally felled for valuable wood.

A stone’s throw from the city’s urban centre are forests that are home to trees that produce fragrant agarwood, used in high-end products from incense and perfume to traditional Chinese medicine.

Environmentalists say illegal incense tree felling is on the rise in Hong Kong, fuelled by black market demand.

Scientists like Dr Zhang are fighting back by taking DNA samples from each plant and creating a database that can help the authorities crack down – as well as offer insights into how the trees can be better conserved.

“In one night, over 20 trees were cut down by poachers,” Dr Zhang, a researcher at Kadoorie Farm and Botanic Garden, said. “We have to take action.”

Hong Kong has long been a hub for sweet-smelling aromatic products. The city’s name – translating to “fragrant harbour” – is commonly linked to the area’s history of incense production and sale.

Agarwood is created when incense trees are cut, which causes the plant to produce a dark resin to prevent infection.

The product then takes the form of fragrant resinous wood.

‘Black gold’

The Hong Kong authorities say illegal incense tree felling soared twelvefold in 2023 compared with the previous year.

Often described as “black gold”, the highest-grade products can fetch up to US$10,000 (S$13,400) per kilo.

The International Union for Conservation of Nature has labelled Chinese agarwood as vulnerable – blaming logging and wood harvesting for the population decline.

Aiming to reverse that, Dr Zhang and other field researchers hiked for hours through swathes of Hong Kong’s dense jungle to access remote populations of incense trees.

Rural communities keen to protect the forests near their homes also assisted in developing the incense tree database.

“We have communication with those villages, and they share information with us about the remaining trees, and we also share our findings with them,” he said.

The database serves a joint purpose: assisting the authorities in stopping illegal incense tree felling and helping researchers understand the species’ evolutionary potential.

Dr Zhang noted that the research has identified unique genetic groups in different areas of Hong Kong – diversity that could be key to cultivating a resilient wild population of the vulnerable species.

Larger genetic diversity protects populations from environmental changes, he said.

For Hong Kong’s incense trees, that includes the effects of climate change and surges in logging activity.

This information lets conservationists know where to transplant certain incense trees from nurseries into the wild.

The authorities can then use this genetic data to cross-reference seized agarwood and check if it was taken from protected trees.

Hong Kong shop owner Aaron Tang sells wares that attest to the many uses of agarwood, from carved jewellery to oils to hand-rolled joss sticks.

To help protect the wild agarwood population, he said he verifies with raw material suppliers that their product comes from cultivated trees. And when he teaches a class on making joss sticks, he warns his students against buying wild stock, or falling for illegally obtained products.

“The name of Hong Kong is because of agarwood so I want to keep this culture,” he said.

‘Gone completely’

Unlike sustainable agarwood producers, the illegal ones create deep cuts on the tree in a bid to make it produce agarwood more quickly.

Then “they chop down the whole tree” for harvesting, Chinese University of Hong Kong scientist David Lau said, pointing to a preserved incense tree trunk on campus.

A spokesman for the city said patrols have been set up at “specific locations with important incense tree populations”.

The authorities insisted that illegal felling has decreased since measures were implemented in 2018, including metal cages and surveillance around the most accessible trees.

But horticulturist Paul Melsom attributes the fall to there being “less trees to poach”.

And the illegal trade has continued to thrive despite government efforts.

In 2024, Hong Kong’s Customs department said it seized a tonne of agarwood in a single operation – its largest haul in two decades.

The authorities estimated it was worth about US$2.3 million.

“The trees have been cut down and gone completely in many forests in Hong Kong,” Mr Melsom said, adding he has been planting incense trees in secret locations for over a decade in response.

“I’ve seen many incense trees disappear,” he said. AFP