Debrief: China's aerial incursions into Taiwan's air defence zone

At least 150 Chinese military warplanes, including bombers, fighter jets and anti-submarine aircraft, have entered Taiwan's ADIZ in the past week.
At least 150 Chinese military warplanes, including bombers, fighter jets and anti-submarine aircraft, have entered Taiwan's ADIZ in the past week.PHOTO: EPA-EFE

SINGAPORE - Air defence identification zones (ADIZs) are in the spotlight again, after China started its latest round of aerial incursions into Taiwan's air defence zone last Friday (Oct 1) when the country marked its 72nd national day.

At least 150 Chinese military warplanes, including bombers, fighter jets and anti-submarine aircraft, have entered Taiwan's ADIZ in the past week.

What is an ADIZ

It is unilaterally declared by a country or a territory for various reasons, including safeguarding of security.

The Chicago Convention on International Civil Aviation in 1944 defined an ADIZ as a "special designated airspace" and aircraft are required to seek permission before entering the zone.

It is different from territorial airspace. The American Journal of International Law cites that a state's territorial waters, and hence its sovereign territorial airspace, ends 12 nautical miles from its coastline. An ADIZ can cover a much larger space and sometimes even overlap the ADIZs of neighbouring states.

Because of its larger size, an ADIZ gives a state or territory some time to scramble its jets to intercept intruding aircraft.

The United States declared the world's first ADIZ during the early Cold War era in 1950 to protect against surprise attacks by Soviet Union bombers. Other places with ADIZs include China, Japan, South Korea and Taiwan.

Why it is useful

If ADIZ boundaries are respected, the zone will help to reduce the risk of accidental collisions and the need to send warplanes to inspect intrusions.

In 1960, for example, the Soviet Union did not have an ADIZ and the resulting confusion led to a US spy plane being shot down over international waters.

Why it can be contentious

Demarcating zones can become contentious, particularly when one country's unilateral declaration overlaps with that of another nation.

For example, in 2013, Japan and China separately declared ADIZs in the East China Sea that covered the disputed Senkaku or Diaoyu islands.

In a testimony to the US House of Foreign Affairs, Dr Peter Dutton, a director of the China Maritime Studies Institute at the US Naval War College, said China sought to use its 2013 declaration to assert its legitimacy to operate within the ADIZ, an act seen as provocative by Japan given the contest over the territory.

Retired Indian fighter pilot PI Muralidharan also said in a report for think-tank Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies that an ADIZ does not equate to territorial boundary, nor would it justify interfering in another state's aerial navigation rights, especially in peacetime.

Meantime, Taiwan's ADIZ, established in 1953, extends into mainland China. But defence analyst Gerald Brown said Taiwan does not record flights over the mainland as aerial incursions, only doing so when a Chinese aircraft leaves its airspace and enters Taiwan's ADIZ, often by crossing the median line of the Taiwan Strait.

Why it matters to China

China does not recognise the median line. Last year, foreign ministry spokesman Wang Wenbin claimed Taiwan as an "inalienable part" of the mainland, flatly rejecting the notion of a line dividing the strait.

China's interests in ADIZs appear to be multi-fold, according to Ms Mercedes Trent, a research associate for the Federation of American Scientists.

She said in a report that besides displaying its air supremacy, unauthorised incursions could help the People's Liberation Army (PLA) gather intelligence on other militaries as the crossings will trigger procedural responses.

Regular incursions could also provide long-range flight training for its pilots that include interaction with foreign air forces.

According to the US Defence Intelligence Agency, the PLA, by maintaining a regular presence in Taiwan's ADIZ, is preparing for contingencies in the Taiwan Strait "to deter and compel Taiwan to abandon moves toward independence".

There are also fears that China may declare an ADIZ over the disputed South China Sea. It has laid claim to nearly all of the waters, angering others with competing claims - Taiwan, Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia and Brunei .

Why it matters to Taiwan

Taiwan's Defence Minister Chiu Kuo-cheng has predicted that China could be ready to mount an invasion of the island by 2025.

Taiwan has labelled China's repeated flybys as "grey zone" warfare. Taiwanese military expert Lu Li-shih said the PLA's planes could have been deployed to wear out Taiwan's defence forces by forcing them to scramble and intercept encroaching planes, and also to gather intelligence on its response procedures.

According to its Ministry of National Defence, the island has seen over 600 incursions by PLA planes so far this year, up from 380 last year. Its defence forces had to scramble 2,972 times to intercept Chinese aircraft last year at a hefty cost of T$25.5 billion (S$1.24 billion).

Taiwan International Strategic Study Society chairman Wang Kung-yi said PLA planes not intercepted could take just 200 seconds to reach Hsinchu, the island's closest point to the Taiwan Strait's median line.

According to the Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies, China's actions may lead to miscalculations, or worse, aerial clashes with the "potential to trigger wider conflict".

What may happen

Analysts expect Beijing to mount another bout of aerial drills into Taiwan's ADIZ to coincide with the island's national day on Sunday.

Threats of a Chinese attack could further unite Taiwanese public opinion behind its current government, experts say.

Last year, President Tsai Ing-wen sealed a second term with a record haul of votes after an election clouded by Chinese President Xi Jinping signalling his intent on reuniting Taiwan with the mainland, with force if necessary.