Australia nears social media ban for children after heated debate

SYDNEY – Australia on Nov 27 moved closer to banning social media for children under 16 after Parliament’s Lower House passed the Bill, even as Alphabet’s Google and Facebook-owner Meta pressed the government to delay the legislation.

Australia’s House of Representatives passed the Bill 102 votes to 13 after Prime Minister Anthony Albanese’s centre-left Labor government secured bipartisan support for the ban.

The landmark Bill is set to be debated by the Senate, with the government keen to ensure that it is passed by the end of the parliamentary year on Nov 28.

Mr Albanese, in trying to lift his approval ratings ahead of an election expected in May, has argued that excessive use of social media poses risks to the physical and mental health of children, and is looking for support from parents.

The planned law would force social media platforms to take reasonable steps to ensure age-verification protections are in place.

Companies could be fined up to A$49.5 million (S$43.1 million) for systemic breaches.

Australia plans to trial an age-verification system that may include biometrics or government identification to enforce a social media age cut-off, some of the toughest controls imposed by any country to date.

A Senate committee late on Nov 26 backed the Bill but inserted a condition that social media platforms should not force users to submit personal data such as passport and other digital identification to prove their age.

The committee added that the government must “meaningfully engage” with young people when framing the law.

“Young people, and in particular diverse cohorts, must be at the centre of the conversation as an age restriction is implemented to ensure there are constructive pathways for connection,” committee chair Senator Karen Grogan said.

In separate submissions, Google and Meta said the social media ban should be delayed until the age-verification trial finishes. ByteDance’s TikTok said the Bill needed more consultation, while Mr Elon Musk’s X said the proposed law might hurt children’s human rights.

The ban was first announced during an emotionally charged parliamentary inquiry into social media, which included testimony from parents of children who had self-harmed due to cyber bullying.

It has fuelled vigorous debate, with youth advocates arguing it robs children of a voice and parent groups saying under-16s are too young to navigate the digital world.

Teenagers have said the law could cut them off from their most important social and family connections, arguing that a ban is not the solution.

“I understand that using social media a lot is not a good thing and I’m working on it,” said Sydney high-school student Enie Lam, 16. “But a ban is not going to work,” she said.

Mr Albanese’s party, which does not control the Senate, won crucial support from the opposition conservatives for the Bill, but has failed to win over the left-leaning Greens and some far-right lawmakers on civil liberties and privacy grounds.

One conservative Lower House member broke from his party and voted against the Bill on Nov 27, a rare event in Australian politics. Two conservative senators said they would also vote against it, arguing that the law should be delayed until the age-verification trial was completed.

Even the Australian Human Rights Commission, an independent statutory authority, opposed the ban, saying it violated children’s rights to self-expression and to participate in society.

Still, polling shows public support overwhelmingly in favour of the move. A YouGov survey released this week showed 77 per cent of Australians backed the ban, up from 61 per cent in August.

Australian media, from the publicly owned Australian Broadcasting Corp to Mr Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp, also support the ban.

An editorial campaign by News Corp, the country’s biggest newspaper publisher, pushed for the ban under the banner “Let Them Be Kids”.

Ms Jenny Branch-Allen, president of the Australian Parents Council, an advocacy group, said: “Our members feel that this is one of the biggest issues impacting on themselves and their families at the moment.

“Big companies have to start taking responsibility.

“Let’s try and reduce the incidents we’re hearing involved with social media and young people in Australia.” REUTERS