LTA to buy $1b of SMRT assets under new rail financing framework

From October 1, SMRT will focus fully on meeting service standards and will pay an annual licensing fee to run their MRT and LRT lines.
SMRT assets will be bought over at around $1 billion, with trains making up the bulk of the value.
SMRT assets will be bought over at around $1 billion, with trains making up the bulk of the value.PHOTO: ST FILE
Under the new framework, SMRT will pay a licensing charge annually to run the North-South and East-West Lines (NSEWL), the Circle Line (CCL) and the Bukit Panjang LRT (BPLRT).
Under the new framework, SMRT will pay a licensing charge annually to run the North-South and East-West Lines (NSEWL), the Circle Line (CCL) and the Bukit Panjang LRT (BPLRT).PHOTO: ST FILE
The train operator will have to abide by a more stringent maintenance regimen, as well as service standards.
The train operator will have to abide by a more stringent maintenance regimen, as well as service standards.PHOTO: ST FILE
(From left) SMRT Trains Managing Director Lee Ling Wee, President and Group CEO  Desmond Kuek and Group Chief Financial Officer Manfred Seah addressing the press conference on LTA taking over its assets.
(From left) SMRT Trains Managing Director Lee Ling Wee, President and Group CEO Desmond Kuek and Group Chief Financial Officer Manfred Seah addressing the press conference on LTA taking over its assets. ST PHOTO: DESMOND WEE

SINGAPORE - After more than four years of intense negotiations, the Government and rail operator SMRT Corp have reached an agreement to switch to a dramatically different arrangement that is designed to improve service.

The Transport Ministry announced on Friday (July 15) that the Land Transport Authority will take over all operating assets of the North-South, East-West and Circle lines as well as the Bukit Panjang LRT Line, from SMRT for $1.06 billion. This is the the net book value – or current value – of the assets, plus GST.

In turn, SMRT will run the trains on these lines and retain a share of the earnings. But it will have to pay a licence charge to LTA annually. The fee, which varies according to SMRT’s profitability, will go into a sinking fund for asset replacement.

The operator will also have to abide by a more stringent maintenance regimen, as well as higher service standards. If it fails to do so, it faces more financial penalties on top of the current ones in place now. 

To reflect its asset-light status, SMRT is expected to post an average EBIT (earnings before interest and taxes) margin of 5 per cent – about one-third of what it made in the last five years.

The new framework will also have a risk-and-reward sharing formula. If SMRT makes substantially more, the government can cream off some in the form of a higher licence fee. But if its margin is crimped by new regulations or fare changes, the fee can likewise be reduced.

Asked why the government is not applying the same model as the new government bus contracts – where operators bid to run services for a fixed fee and the LTA collects all fare revenue, Transport Ministry permanent secretary Pang Kin Keong said: “It was a judgment call. We wanted to have the operator to still have some skin in the game. We wanted them to do things that will attract ridership.”

Pending approval from its shareholders, SMRT will start a new 15-year contract under the new framework from Oct 1.


PHOTO: FACEBOOK/LAND TRANSPORT AUTHORITY

It will thus operate the four lines up till 2031, with an option for a five-year extension.

Under the current system, SMRT’s North-South, East-West lines and Bukit Panjang LRT contract expires in 2028, while its Circle Line deal expires in 2019. Both come with an option for a 30-year extension. 

The shorter tenure now makes it easier for the LTA to replace an operator that has consistently poor performance.

SMRT added that the current system had become “unsustainable”, as it is obliged to comply with changes in regulatory standards “at its own cost”. Over the next five years, the company estimates that its capital expenditure could reach $2.8 billion.

Chief executive Desmond Kuek said the new framework will allow the company “to better focus on fulfilling its role as a public transport operator to deliver high levels of operational reliability, safety, and service for the benefit of our commuters”.

SMRT will call for an extraordinary general meeting to seek shareholders’ approval for the proposed asset sale to LTA soon. It said it does not intend to distribute the proceeds of the sale in the form of a special dividend.