No commercial columbarium in Sengkang's Fernvale Lea: 7 things about the controversy

SINGAPORE - National Development Minister Khaw Boon Wan said on Jan 29 there will be no commercial columbarium at the proposed temple site in Sengkang, the latest development in a controversy which has upset some residents.

Speaking in Parliament, Mr Khaw said the site, which is next to a Build-To-Order (BTO) project called Fernvale Lea, was awarded to Eternal Pure Land under the impression that the company was a vehicle for a religious organisation to build and own a Chinese temple.

"We now understand that the winning tenderer for this site, Eternal Pure Land Pte Ltd, is actually a private company without any religious affiliation," he said. "From what we know, the plan of the company is to run a commercial columbarium on the site. This is not in line with our plan for the place-of-worship site."

Here's a look back at the controversy:

1. What was said in Parliament?

Nm columbarium2

National Development Minister Khaw Boon Wan said his ministry will ensure that the land next to Fernvale Lea is restored to the original plan of a Chinese temple. The authorities are in discussion with Eternal Pure Land on how that can be achieved.

Future Fernvale Lea residents mostly relieved over no-go for commercial columbarium

Parliament: There will be no commercial columbarium in Fernvale: Khaw Boon Wan

Sengkang columbarium: Khaw Boon Wan takes questions from MPs


2. What is the tender process like for sites set aside for religious use?

Sjcolumbarium300115

The case of Eternal Pure Land, a commercial entity, winning the bid for a temple site in Sengkang has raised questions on land-use models and the tender process.

5 things about the tender of government land for religious uses


3.  Why are residents upset with the columbarium plans?

Nm columbarium4Residents were annoyed that the site was not clearly marked as being used for a columbarium. They said the possibility of a columbarium at the site of the temple was in fine print, and the Housing Board (HDB) did not make that clear to them. Some did not like the idea of living next to the dead, or were concerned about the resale value of their flats. Some also did not like how a religious site was given to a commercial entity.

How the columbarium saga unfolded

Future residents of Fernvale Lea BTO in Sengkang West surprised by columbarium plan

Columbarium issue sparks calls for flat refunds

Columbarium issue sparks calls for flat refunds

Chinese temple with columbarium in Sengkang to cost $20 million


4. What did the authorities and Eternal Pure Land say?

Nm columbarium1

HDB and the Urban Redevelopment Authority had said earlier they will ensure that the proposed temple will integrate well with the surrounding developments, the same way other existing places of worship with columbarium space have been integrated in many residential estates.

Columbarium in Sengkang Fernvale Link 'will be out of public view'

Columbarium builder committed to run temple at Fernvale Link

Life Corporation says Sengkang temple and columbarium plan was 'open and transparent'


5.  Are there columbariums in other housing estates?

Nm columbarium6

The opposition among would-be residents of Fernvale Lea does not seem to be mirrored in other areas of Singapore that already accommodate such facilities.

The Straits Times spoke to 30 residents living near three columbariums nestled within residential areas and found a general level of acceptance.

Residents in other estates don't mind living near columbariums


6.  What are some of the issues highlighted in the controversy?

Nm columbarium5

Some have questioned whether commercial entities, like Eternal Pure, should be allowed to bid for sites earmarked for places of worship. Observers say the episode offers an opportunity for dialogue on land-use models and review of tender process.

Should businesses be allowed to outbid faith groups for religious sites?

Overseas entities getting into business of after-death services in Singapore


7. What are the rules governing death-related facilities and sites here?

Nm church 2901Columbarium in Sengkang: FAQ on death-related facilities and sites in Singapore