SINGAPORE (BLOOMBERG) - Singapore's stocks are set for a 15 per cent tumble this year, putting them in the same league as Greece. Baring Asset Management and UBS Group say shares need to get even cheaper before they're prepared to buy.
Commodity trader Noble Group and oil-rig builder Sembcorp Marine are down at least 46 per cent in 2015 amid a raw-materials price rout, while DBS Group Holdings has been the biggest drag on the Straits Times Index as property prices decline and bad debts increase.
Among developed markets tracked by Bloomberg, the only benchmark measure that has fared worse is the ASE Index in Athens, which is poised for a 24 per cent plunge.
"While some value could emerge if Singapore drops another 10 per cent, there's not a lot of things to be wildly excited about Singapore at the moment," said Soo Hai Lim, a Hong Kong-based money manager at Baring. "Cheap valuations aren't a good enough reason why these stocks would deliver the kind of performance we're looking for. The growth outlook is still quite soft for 2016."
Following this year's slump, shares on the MSCI Singapore Index trade at 1.1 times the value of its companies' net assets, compared with a multiple of 2 on a measure of global equities. The gap between the two widened this month to the most since May 2003. The MSCI Asia Pacific Index is heading for a 5.7 per cent retreat in 2015.
While attractive valuations may spur a rebound in the early part of next year, the outlook for the whole year still looks pessimistic, according to Mixo Das, a strategist at Nomura Holdings.
"Growth overall is slowing, particularly in China, and that raises the risk for the earnings of banks and commodity companies," Das said. "That's going to drag on Singapore valuations."
MSCI Inc reclassified Greece as an emerging market in November 2013, while fellow index compiler FTSE still considers Greece as a developed market.
Foreign investors have pulled US$6.7 billion from Thai, Philippine and Indonesian equity markets this year amid concerns the first US interest-rate increase in almost a decade and a weakening Chinese economy will further curb the region's economic growth.
While Singapore averted recession in the third quarter, the Monetary Authority of Singapore has warned weaker corporate balance sheets and currency market volatility pose risks to the nation's lenders.
"The banks have exposure to the Southeast Asia region," Kelvin Tay, regional chief investment officer at UBS's wealth management business in Singapore, said by phone. "Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia aren't doing particularly well."
The non-performing loan ratio among Singapore banks rose to 1.5 per cent in the third quarter of 2015, from 1.1 per cent a year earlier, the central bank said in November. Bad loans have increased in the manufacturing sector, and banks with exposure to trade may see higher credit risks, the monetary authority said.
Still, Nader Naeimi, Sydney-based head of dynamic markets at AMP Capital Investors Ltd, said he is staying optimistic because rising interest rates should help boost bank profitability. Borrowing costs in Singapore were rising even before the Federal Reserve increased US interest rates this month for the first time since 2006, helping to lift lender DBS Group's interest margins in the third quarter to a four-year high.
Singapore lenders including DBS Group, Oversea-Chinese Banking Corp. and United Overseas Bank Ltd account for about 35 per cent of the benchmark Straits Times Index, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
"The key drag here is the banks," said Nomura's Das. "Loan growth is weak and is likely to remain so."
While Nomura's Das expects the Straits Times Index to end 2016 little changed from current levels, other brokerages are more optimistic, with Credit Suisse Group forecasting an advance to 3,000 and RHB Securities Pte expecting a 12 per cent gain by December next year from Monday's close. Still, Bank Julius Baer & Co says it's too early to buy.
"The growth outlook isn't great," Jen Chua, an analyst at Bank Julius Baer in Singapore, said by phone. "Though the downside from here may be limited, we won't get too positive on the market for now."