White House says Democrats will never see Trump's tax returns

White House Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney dismissed an effort to obtain US President Donald Trump's tax returns on April 7, 2019.
White House Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney dismissed an effort to obtain US President Donald Trump's tax returns on April 7, 2019.PHOTO: EPA-EFE

WASHINGTON (REUTERS) - President Donald Trump’s tax returns will never be handed over to Democratic lawmakers, White House Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney said on Sunday (April 7), defying an effort in Congress to learn more about the real estate mogul’s personal finances.

Asked on Fox News Sunday if congressional Democrats will succeed in obtaining the Republican President’s tax returns, Mr Mulvaney said: “No, never. Nor should they.”

He dismissed an effort to obtain the returns, launched last Wednesday by United States House of Representatives tax committee chairman Richard Neal, as a political ploy from Democrats who will never stop attacking Mr Trump.

“Democrats are demanding that the IRS turn over the documents. That is not going to happen, and they know it. This is a political stunt,” Mr Mulvaney said. 

Democrats countered that Mr Neal’s request to the Treasury Department for Mr Trump’s returns is grounded in law and a needed inquiry, given Mr Trump’s refusal to disclose his tax records and to divest himself of his business interests. 

“This is a legitimate authority that the Congress has. This President, by the way, is the least transparent president that we’ve had in half a century,” Democratic Representative Dan Kildee, a tax committee member, told ABC’s This Week.

Democratic Representative Ben Ray Lujan noted that presidents for decades have voluntarily released their income tax returns.

 
 
 

“This is not political, as our Republican colleagues are making it out to be,” he told Fox News Sunday.

An attorney for Mr Trump last Friday blasted House Democrats’ request for six years of Mr Trump’s personal and business returns as “a misguided attempt” to politicise the tax laws, accusing lawmakers of harassment and interference in IRS audits.

In a statement that mapped out the legal battlefield ahead, Trump lawyer William Consovoy said the request filed by Mr Neal flouts “constitutional constraints”.

Republican Senator Mitt Romney urged Mr Trump to release his tax returns as promised but criticised Democratic efforts to force the issue through legislative action as “moronic”.

“The courts are not going to say that you can compel a person running for office to release their tax returns,” he said on NBC’s Meet The Press.

One of many investigations targeting Mr Trump on Capitol Hill and in the US court system, the House Democrats’ probe into the President’s tax returns could pull back the curtain on his business empire and his reputation as a dealmaker. 

As a presidential candidate in 2016, Mr Trump broke with a decades-old practice of making his tax returns public and continues to refuse to release them as president, while retaining ownership in many enterprises, ranging from golf courses and hotels and other properties.

If Congress takes the administration to court over Mr Trump’s taxes, then little case law would be available to help guide judges, legal experts said, both because the statute cited by Mr Neal to obtain the returns has hardly ever been contested, and because most document disputes between the legislative and executive branches of government are resolved by negotiation. 

The losing party could appeal, ultimately to the US Supreme Court. If litigation extends into 2021, a judge could also force a newly elected Congress to start the process over, said Mr Ross Garber, an attorney who specialises in political investigations.