Trump’s foreign policy called imperialist by experts

WASHINGTON - US President Donald Trump has made a series of controversial moves that have shaken up the world order, including a military raid that toppled Venezuela’s leader and renewed threats to annex Greenland.

Mr Trump, who campaigned on what was seen as an isolationist “America First” platform, defends his policies as advancing US economic and security interests. But to many experts, his moves echo the actions of 19th-century colonial powers.

Here are some of the Trump administration’s most significant and controversial international actions and the reactions of experts to those moves:

Gaza governance proposal

In February 2025, Mr Trump said the US will take over Gaza before gradually dropping that position – which was condemned by the United Nations as a proposal for “ethnic cleansing” – over the course of the year.

In another proposal that started a fragile ceasefire in Gaza in October, Mr Trump said Gaza’s temporary governance will be overseen by a so-called “Board of Peace” of which Mr Trump himself will be the chair.

Israel and Hamas signed off on that Trump plan and a UN Security Council resolution authorised that board to establish a temporary international force in Gaza.

Many experts said it resembled a colonial structure, with Mr Trump chairing a board to oversee a foreign territory’s governance. UN special adviser on sustainability Jeffrey Sachs called it “imperialism masquerading as a peace process” while multiple UN experts cast it as “regrettably reminiscent of colonial practices”.

Venezuela raid and oil interest

In early January, Mr Trump ordered a deadly US military raid in Venezuela that led to the seizure of ousted Venezuelan leader Nicolas Maduro and his wife, who were subsequently brought to New York to face trial.

Mr Trump said Washington will “run” Venezuela where Maduro’s former vice-president, Ms Delcy Rodriguez, became interim president and is governing the country under US oversight. Mr Trump said major US oil companies would move into Venezuela, which has the world’s largest oil reserves.

Critics said Mr Trump’s focus on exploiting Venezuelan oil raised questions about his administration’s efforts to frame the capture of Maduro as a law enforcement action aimed at reducing drug trafficking.

The UN human rights office says US actions in Venezuela were a violation of international law that made the world less safe.

“In practice, the President's policies smack of neo-imperialism, not neo-isolationism,” Dr Charles Kupchan, a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations and a professor at Georgetown University, wrote. He also noted Mr Trump’s threats against Mexico, Columbia and Greenland after the Venezuela raid.

Greenland threat

Mr Trump has repeatedly said Washington must own Greenland, an autonomous part of the Kingdom of Denmark that houses a US air base, to prevent Russia or China from occupying the strategically located and minerals-rich Arctic territory.

He says a US military presence there is not enough. Greenland and Denmark have said that Greenland is not for sale, but Mr Trump has not ruled out taking it by force. Denmark and the US are NATO members.

“In opting out of this consensus, the US risks assuming the position of a rogue state within the international system,” Mr Marc Weller, the director of the International Law Programme at the Chatham House think-tank, said.

Mr Trump has also threatened to make Canada the 51st state of the US but has not mentioned that in recent months. REUTERS