IMF says US companies are paying China tariff costs, contrary to Trump view

The International Monetary Fund said that consumers in the United States and China are "unequivocally the losers" from recent trade tensions between the two countries.
The International Monetary Fund said that consumers in the United States and China are "unequivocally the losers" from recent trade tensions between the two countries.PHOTO: AFP

WASHINGTON (BLOOMBERG) - Companies in the United States are paying almost all the costs from tariffs on Chinese imports, International Monetary Fund (IMF) researchers said in findings that contradict US President Donald Trump's assertions that China is footing the bill.

The researchers found "tariff revenue collected has been borne almost entirely by US importers", according to the IMF's blog post released on Thursday (May 23).

"Some of these tariffs have been passed on to US consumers, like those on washing machines, while others have been absorbed by importing firms through lower profit margins."

The report concludes what most private economists have argued for months: that China doesn't pay US tariffs, American consumers and companies do.

"Consumers in the US and China are unequivocally the losers from trade tensions," the IMF paper said.

It is rare for the IMF to disagree with its largest shareholder, and the paper was released just as the rhetoric in Mr Trump's trade war with China reaches a boiling point.

"For 10 months, China has been paying Tariffs to the USA of 25% on 50 Billion Dollars of High Tech, and 10% on 200 Billion Dollars of other goods," Mr Trump tweeted on May 5.

Trade talks between Beijing and Washington stalled this month as Mr Trump accused China of backing out of a deal that was taking shape.

 
 
 
 
 

In response, Trump increased levies on US$200 billion (S$276 billion) in Chinese imports to 25 per cent from 10 per cent, prompting retaliation from Beijing.

According to a separate report on Thursday from researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, the US' 15 percentage point increase in tariffs will result in an annual cost of US$831 per American household, about double the bill on Mr Trump's 2018 tariffs.

The US has also released a list of about US$300 billion in Chinese goods that could face additional tariffs, including clothing, toys and mobile phones. Those levies, if imposed, would cover essentially all Chinese imports and hit a broader swathe of American households.

Earlier this month, White House economic director Larry Kudlow acknowledged "both sides will suffer" from the widening US-China trade war, while predicting that the impact on US jobs and growth from higher tariffs on Chinese goods would be "de minimis".

On Thursday, China blamed Washington for wrecking the talks and insisted the US must alter its "wrong practices" before negotiations can resume.

Financial markets, meanwhile, are slumping amid prospects for a long dispute between the world's two largest economies.

Co-written by IMF chief economist Gita Gopinath, the paper says a trade war that escalates with all the threatened tariffs will subtract about a third of a percentage point from global gross domestic product, "with half stemming from business and market confidence effects".

"This type of scenario is among the reasons why we referred to 2019 as a delicate year for the global economy," the IMF economists wrote.

In April, the fund cut its 2019 forecast for global growth to 3.3 per cent, the lowest since the financial crisis, citing higher tariffs weighing on trade and weakness in some advanced economies.