Humans worse than other predators

Protesters from People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals with pictures of Cecil, the lion killed by an American trophy hunter in a Zimbabwe national park recently.
Protesters from People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals with pictures of Cecil, the lion killed by an American trophy hunter in a Zimbabwe national park recently. PHOTO: AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE

Study says man's approach to hunting is wiping out species on land and in water

MIAMI • Humans are super predators that upset the natural balance on earth by killing far too many adult animals and fish, scientists said, urging a focus on catching fewer and smaller creatures.

People tend to kill adult fish at 14 times the rate of marine predators, said the findings in the journal Science. And humans slaughter large land carnivores such as bears and lions at nine times the rate of predatory animals in the wild.

Based on a survey of 2,125 predators around the world on land and in the water, scientists found that people cause "extreme outcomes that non-human predators seldom impose", said co-author Chris Darimont, professor of geography at the University of Victoria in British Columbia, Canada.

These include extinctions, shrinking fish numbers and disruptions to global food chains. These impacts are made possible by humans' unique approach to hunting - using weapons and external energy sources like fuel to power our hunts, searching for the biggest catch possible and acting as suppliers for other hungry mouths in faraway places, Prof Darimont said. This is in sharp contrast to the way the marine world operates, with predators taking only 1 per cent of adult prey.

If humans want to continue to see large beasts like rhinos, elephants and lions in the wild, as well as ensure the health of ocean life, scientists said big changes are needed.

"We're suggesting a new and perhaps transformative way to consider what sustainable exploitation could be," he said.

He said the recent outrage over the killing of Cecil the lion may be an indicator that societies are ready to at least cut back, if not stop, trophy hunting of large beasts.

"If future generations of people are to see these magnificent animals, then this requires cultivating new tolerance for living with them," he said. "This might include increasing revenues to local communities derived not from hunting, but from non-consumptive uses such as eco-tourism, shooting carnivores with cameras, not guns."

When it comes to fishing, Prof Darimont and his co-author Tom Reimchen urged a focus on younger, smaller fish.

Humans now tend to focus on catching the biggest fish, because they provide more food and they are easier to process than smaller fish, which are often thrown back. But these adult fish are valuable when it comes to reproduction, and should be spared, the study says.

Professor Reimchen's research shows predatory fish and diving birds overwhelmingly kill juvenile forms of freshwater fish and take no more than 2 per cent of the adult fish. Salmon fisheries run by people harvest about half of all adult fish.

An accompanying editorial says humans "have the unusual ability to analyse and consciously adjust our behaviour to minimise deleterious consequences. This final point... will prove critical for our continued coexistence with viable wildlife populations on land and in the sea".


A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on August 22, 2015, with the headline 'Humans worse than other predators'. Print Edition | Subscribe