Pope defends nativity scenes in public places

A camel, sheep and a lighted Christmas tree in the background feature in this nativity scene in Cathedral Square, Vilnius, Lithuania.
A camel, sheep and a lighted Christmas tree in the background feature in this nativity scene in Cathedral Square, Vilnius, Lithuania.PHOTO: ASSOCIATED PRESS

ROME • Pope Francis has defended the display of nativity scenes in town squares and other public places, which has become an annual contentious issue at Christmas time in countries such as the United States and France.

The Pope travelled to the town of Greccio, east of Rome, to visit the spot where St Francis of Assisi started the tradition by setting up the first nativity scene in 1223.

There, the Pope signed a papal document known as an Apostolic Letter and titled Admirabile Signum (Wonderful Sign), on the meaning and importance of the nativity scene.

"With this letter, I wish to encourage the beautiful family tradition of preparing the nativity scene in the days before Christmas, but also the custom of setting it up in the workplace, in schools, hospitals, prisons and town squares," the document says.

Nativity scenes depict the birth of Jesus as Christians believe it took place - the baby and his mother posed in a humble stable setting with animals and shepherds, and kings bearing gifts who arrived days later.

The construction of such scenes in public squares or on government property is contested regularly by atheist, free speech or secularist groups.

In the US, groups opposed to nativity scenes in public places say they violate the First Amendment of the US Constitution, which prohibits the establishment of a state religion.

In 1984, the US Supreme Court ruled in favour of allowing nativity scenes in public places, saying that they were not an effort to establish or support a particular religion and also possessed what the court called "legitimate secular purposes".

Even after that ruling, American groups have regularly challenged their use or have demanded equal space on public property to promote their non-religious views.


In 2014 in France, a court order to dismantle a nativity scene in a town hall because it violated the country's secular tradition prompted a backlash, which won support from right-wing politicians.

In other parts of the document, the Pope said last Saturday that the purpose of the nativity scene was to teach "that we cannot let ourselves be fooled by wealth and fleeting promises of happiness" and that they were a reminder to help those less fortunate.

Earlier, Pope Francis urged people to resist the excesses of consumerism in the period leading up to Christmas.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Straits Times on December 03, 2019, with the headline 'Pope defends nativity scenes in public places'. Print Edition | Subscribe