Anger grows as Italy bridge collapse kills 39, operator comes under fire

Rescuers work into the night at the site of the Morandi viaduct, upon which the A10 motorway runs, that collapsed in Genoa, Italy, on Aug 14, 2018.
Rescuers work into the night at the site of the Morandi viaduct, upon which the A10 motorway runs, that collapsed in Genoa, Italy, on Aug 14, 2018.PHOTO: EPA-EFE

MILAN (REUTERS) - Rescuers searched for survivors amid the debris of Italy's bridge collapse on Wednesday (Aug 15) as the death toll climbed to 39 and the government blamed the bridge’s operator, demanding resignations and moving to strip its toll concession.

The 50-year-old bridge, part of a toll motorway linking the port city of Genoa with southern France, collapsed during torrential rain on Tuesday (Aug 14), sending dozens of vehicles crashing onto a riverbed, a railway and two warehouses.

Singapore President Halimah Yacob on Wednesday expressed her condolences to her Italian counterpart Sergio Mattarella, saying that she was saddened to hear of the tragic loss of life and injury caused by the collapse of the motorway bridge.

“On behalf of the people of Singapore, I extend our heartfelt sympathies to the families affected by the tragedy,” she said.

Singapore Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, in a letter to Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte, said: “I am confident that Italy will pull together and recover from this tragedy.”

Eyewitness Ivan, 37, evacuated on Tuesday from the nearby building where he works, described the collapse as unbelievable.

“To see a pylon come down like papier-mâché is an incredible thing,” he said. “It’s been a lifetime that we’ve known there were problems. It is in continual maintenance.” 

“In the 90s they added some reinforcements on one part, but also underneath you can see rust.” 

As cranes moved in to shift truck-sized chunks of broken concrete, hundreds of firefighters searched for survivors, while public shock and grief turned to anger over the state of the 1.2km-long bridge, completed in 1967 and overhauled two years ago.

Bridge operator Autostrade, a unit of Milan-listed Atlantia group, said it had carried out regular, sophisticated checks on the structure before the disaster and that these had provided reassuring results.

“Furthermore, the company’s technicians have relied, in order to assess the state of the viaduct and the efficacy of control systems being adopted, on companies and institutions which are world leaders in testing and inspections based on best international practices,” it said in a statement.

But the condition of the bridge, and its ability to sustain large increases in both the intensity and weight of traffic over the years, have been a focus of public debate since Tuesday’s collapse, when an 80-metre span gave way at lunchtime as cars packed with holidaymakers as well as trucks streamed across it.

Deputy Prime Minister and Interior Minister Matteo Salvini said the private sector manager of the bridge had earned “billions” from tolls but “did not spend the money they were supposed to” and its concession should be revoked.

He was apparently referring to Autostrade.

“Imposing the highest penalties possible and making sure that those responsible for the dead and the injured pay up for any damages and crimes is the very least,” he said.

Fire brigade spokesman Luca Cari said 400 firefighters were at the site, lifting big chunks of concrete to create spaces for rescue teams to check for survivors.

In Paris, France’s foreign ministry said three French nationals were among the dead.

Italy’s transport minister said yesterday he had begun a process to strip Autostrade of its concession and he demanded top Autostrade managers resign.

“Autostrade per l’Italia was not able to fulfill its obligations under the contract regulating management of this infrastructure,” Mr Danilo Toninelli said on RAI 1 state TV, adding that he would also seek to levy heavy fines against the company.

“I have given mandate to my ministry to start all proceedings to apply the agreement, that is to revoke the concession from these companies and seek significant sanctions which can reach up to €150 million (S$234 million) based on the terms of the contract.” 


The Morandi Bridge, named after the engineer who designed it, forms part of the A10 motorway run by Autostrade. The 55km  stretch of the A10 accounts for around 1.7 per cent of total network traffic for Italy’s biggest toll road operator, according to one analyst’s estimate.

“The top management of Autostrade per l’Italia must step down first of all,” Mr Toninelli said in a Facebook post.

He also said the government would inspect the structure of ageing bridges and tunnels across the country with a view to launching a programme of remedial works if required.

Within hours of the disaster, the anti-establishment government that took office in June said the collapse showed Italy needed to spend more on its dilapidated infrastructure, ignoring EU budget constraints if necessary.

Genoa police put the death toll at 39, with 16 injured.