ICC sentences Malian militant to nine years for destroying Timbuktu’s ancient shrines

The ruins of a mausoleum seen after it was destroyed by an extremist militant in Timbuktu on July 25, 2013.
The ruins of a mausoleum seen after it was destroyed by an extremist militant in Timbuktu on July 25, 2013.PHOTO: REUTERS

THE HAGUE (REUTERS)– War crimes judges on Tuesday (Sept 27)  sentenced a former Islamist rebel who admitted wrecking holy shrines during Mali’s 2012 conflict to nine years in prison, in the first such case to focus on the destruction of cultural heritage.

Human rights groups and international legal experts hope Ahmad al-Faqi al-Mahdi’s case in the International Criminal Court may serve as a deterrent to a kind of devastation that continues to be a feature of global conflicts yet has gone largely unpunished.

Al-Mahdi expressed remorse for his involvement in the destruction of 10 mausoleums and religious sites in Timbuktu dating from Mali’s 14th-century golden age as a trading hub and centre of Sufi Islam, a branch of the religion seen as idolatrous by some hardline Muslim groups.

The sites, nine of them on the Unesco World Heritage list,“had an emotional and symbolic meaning for the residents of Timbuktu”, the panel of judges at The Hague said.

By striking at their most meaningful religious sites, al-Mahdi participated in “a war activity aimed at breaking the soul of the people,” said presiding Judge Raul Pangalangan.

Specifically, the judges said, he “exercised joint control over the attacks” by planning, leading and participating in them, supplying pick-axes and in one case a bulldozer.

Such acts have rarely been prosecuted despite being illegal under international law, but have attracted increasing international outrage after the Taleban destroyed the Bamiyan Buddha statues in Afghanistan in 2001 and, more recently, Islamic State in Iraq and Syria terrorists smashed monuments in the Syrian city of Palmyra.

Those actions do not fall under the jurisdiction of the ICC because it is limited to prosecuting individuals for crimes committed in member countries, and neither Syria nor Afghanistan have joined the court.


The ICC has been examining events in Mali since 2012, when Tuareg rebels seized part of the north, imposing a strict interpretation of Islamic law. French and Malian troops pushed them back the following year.

During his brief trial in August al-Mahdi asked for forgiveness and said he had been swept up in an “evil wave” when Al-Qaeda and the Ansar Dine Islamist groups briefly seized control of the ancient sites.

Prosecutors and the defense had agreed beforehand to accept a sentence of 9 to 11 years for the former religious teacher, who sat quietly in a gray suit, nodding as the verdict was read aloud.

Judges said the sentence took into account al-Mahdi’s“genuine remorse, deep regret and deep pain” and his calls on other Muslims not to make the same mistakes he did. “Such an admission may have a deterrent effect on others tempted to commit similar acts in Mali and elsewhere,”Pangalangan said.

Unesco said in a statement the verdict was “a landmark in gaining recognition for the importance of heritage for humanity as a whole and for the communities that have preserved it over the centuries”. 

“This case is of phenomenal significance considering the character of armed conflict going on around the world and the amount of cultural property that is being destroyed,” said Carrie Comer, permanent representative to the ICC of Paris-based rights watch dog FIDH.

She said that given al-Mahdi’s remorse and cooperation, the sentence “is quite a strong deterrent message: saying we do take these crimes seriously, they have an impact on victims not only in the immediate vicinity but really on the international community as a whole.” Residents reached in Timbuktu had mixed views about the verdict. 

“Nine years in prison is little. But he deserves the sentence as an example for all who committed these barbaric acts,” said Alhoussaini Saye, a teacher.

Hawa Sisse, a trader in a Timbuktu market, said: “I was expecting him to be imprisoned for life, but (the court) decided otherwise. I hope that his return to Timbuktu in nine years will not be perceived as a sort of victory among the militants.”