Brexit talks in ‘disturbing deadlock’, says EU’s Michel Barnier

Remote video URL
European Union's chief Brexit negotiator Michel Barnier holds a joint news conference with Britain's Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union David Davis after the latest round of talks in Brussels, Belgium Oct 12, 2017. PHOTO: REUTERS

BRUSSELS (AFP) - Britain and the EU are stuck in a "disturbing" deadlock over the Brexit divorce bill, though a breakthrough remains possible in the next two months, EU negotiator Michel Barnier said on Thursday (Oct 12).

The stalemate will stoke fears swirling in London and Brussels of a breakdown in talks that could see Britain leaving the European Union in March 2019 without an agreement to soften the blow.

After a fifth round of talks with Britain's David Davis, Barnier said he could not recommend to EU leaders at a summit next week that negotiations move on from divorce issues to talks on a post- Brexit trade deal.

The Frenchman reserved his most cutting comments for the issue of financial commitments, saying Britain had still not spelled out what Prime Minister Theresa May promised in a key speech in Florence, Italy, last month.

"We are at a deadlock on this question which is extremely disturbing," Barnier said at a press conference with Davis at the European Commission headquarters in Brussels.

May later said the two sides were "very close to agreement" on several issues, while British Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson called for the EU to show "urgency" over the talks.


Speaking a mix of French and English, Barnier said the "constructive" talks had clarified some points but there had not been any "great steps forward" on central issues.

"I am not currently able to recommend to next week's European Council to open discussions on the future relationship," Barnier said.

Remote video URL

The leaders of the 27 other EU countries have demanded there be "sufficient progress" on the Brexit bill, the rights of EU citizens living in Britain, and on Northern Ireland before moving on to discuss a post- Brexit trade deal.

But Barnier added: "I remain convinced that with political will, decisive breakthroughs are within reach in the coming two months." He also warned against the possibility of a so-called "hard Brexit" after May admitted this week that her government was setting aside money for a "no-deal scenario".

"A no deal will be a very bad deal," Barnier said.

May later said the two sides were "very close to agreement" on a number of issues including citizens' rights and welcomed Barnier's recognition that progress could be made in the coming weeks.


Davis, a key figure in the Leave campaign in last year's Brexit referendum, said he still hoped EU leaders could decide to shift to the next phase when they meet next week.

"I hope the member states will recognise the progress we've made and take a step forward in the spirit of the prime minister's Florence speech," Davis said, adding that it was "in the interests of Europe and the UK."

He called on EU leaders to give Barnier a mandate next week to "explore ways forward" on May's proposal for a two-year transition period after Brexit, even if trade talks are not opened.

In Britain, May welcomed Barnier's recognition that progress could be made in the coming weeks and said she wanted to "get to the business of talking about the future relationship."

Johnson, one of Davis's co-Brexiteers, added: "We're looking for some urgency from our friends and partners, and it's time to put a bit of a tiger in the tank and get this thing done."

The possibility of Britain leaving without a deal has suddenly become a reality in recent days, and the failure of negotiators to reach a breakthrough has rattled nerves and markets.

EU President Donald Tusk warned on Tuesday that the bloc might rethink whether a Brexit deal is possible if there is no progress by the end of the year.

Tusk also ruled out the possibility of moving onto the trade talks phase at the Oct 19 summit, though he said he hoped to be able to by the next summit in December.

"If it turns out that the talks continue at a slow pace, and that 'sufficient progress' hasn't been reached, then - together with our UK friends - we will have to think about where we are heading," he said.

Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.