Simba director to resign after telco admits intentional misuse of spectrum bands
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox
The regulator had issued Simba a Show Cause Notice to explain and contest the allegations by Nov 16.
ST PHOTO: LIM YAOHUI
SINGAPORE – Simba has admitted to intentional misuse of spectrum bands and failure to comply with an order from the authorities, following a series of accusations made in October by the country’s telecoms regulator.
In an Australian Securities Exchange filing on Nov 17, Simba’s parent company Tuas said that the telco’s director Richard Tan, who is based in Singapore, will resign subject to regulatory approval, and new directors will be appointed.
It is unclear whether Tan will also step down from his role as chief executive of Simba. ST has contacted the telco and Tuas for more information.
It added that it did not contest the allegations of unauthorised use of the 2,100 megahertz (MHz) band spectrum for 4G, and of unauthorised use of the 2,340MHz to 2360MHz band spectrum at about 92 sites for intermittent periods between 2023 and 2026.
These instances are alleged to have been intentional and approved by Simba’s senior management.
The telco also admitted to unauthorised deployment of 5G network equipment at two locations in 2023, and failure to comply with a production order issued by the Infocomm Media Development Authority (IMDA).
“Simba has informed the IMDA of the circumstances surrounding the unauthorised use of the bands, and the remediation steps put in place by Simba to seek to prevent recurrence,” said Tuas.
“As the matter remains under consideration by the IMDA and no findings have been made or confirmed, Tuas does not intend to provide further comment on the matters raised in this announcement.”
IMDA assigns spectrum frequencies – which are invisible air waves that carry the signals communication systems rely on – to mobile operators in Singapore. Telcos are allowed to use only the spectrum frequency assigned to them.
The regulator had issued Simba a Show Cause Notice to explain and contest the allegations by Nov 16. If Simba fails to explain itself, the telco’s spectrum rights could be suspended or cancelled. The telco might be fined up to $1 million or 10% of its annual Singapore revenue, whichever is higher.
The regulator could also cancel or suspend Simba’s telco licence, or a part of it, or cut the duration of its licence.
The notice escalates an ongoing probe by IMDA into Simba.
In May, it was disclosed that Simba is being investigated by the regulator for unauthorised spectrum use, which contributed to the collapse of the telco’s proposed $1.4 billion acquisition of M1.
For its four breaches, Simba could be fined up to $75 million, which makes up about 40% of the telco’s revenue in the 2026 financial year (FY2026), said DBS analyst Sachin Mittal.
“A maximum fine of up to $75 million can wipe out 90% of the telco’s FY2026 earnings before interest, taxes, and depreciation and amortisation (Ebitda),” said Mittal, who serves as global head of tech, telecom, and automotive research at the bank.
“This could force Simba to raise mobile plan prices for consumers, to account for rising capital expenditure in maintaining its 5G network and upgrading systems to meet cybersecurity standards.”
However, Simba’s admission is generally viewed as “coming clean” and may thus deserve a more lenient punishment, said Bryan Tan, managing consultant at advisory firm Benhke SGS.
He added that IMDA will likely note the planned resignation by director Richard Tan and introduction of new board members, which seek to address governance issues.
If IMDA approves the change in management and board, then a licence cancellation is likely to be ruled out, said Benhke SGS’ Bryan Tan.
Severe penalties like suspension or cancellation of a telco licence are generally reserved for egregious cases, such as if a telco refuses to cooperate or ongoing harm cannot be remediated, said Norvin Chan, associate director at law firm Osborne Clarke Singapore.
“Given Simba’s stated remediation efforts and decision not to contest the allegations, a calibrated financial penalty appears more likely,” he added.
Richard Tan’s planned resignation from his directorship but not from his role as chief executive allows Simba to strengthen board oversight, while limiting any immediate impact to daily operations, said Hussaini Saifee, head of ASEAN telecom media and technology at Maybank Securities Singapore.
He added that Tan was key to Simba’s development, helping the telco achieve profitability and earn 1.46 million mobile subscribers.
Said Hussaini: “If a CEO succession becomes necessary later, an internal appointment could provide continuity, although a permanent successor would ideally combine telecom operating experience with strong regulatory and governance credentials.”
In response to queries from ST, an IMDA spokesperson said the regulator will review Simba’s submission and assess whether the response covers all areas in which the telco is under investigation.
“We will then decide on the appropriate actions to be taken,” said the spokesperson.
