ZIBO, China (AFP) - Images of a beaming Fifa President Sepp Blatter and a small blue certificate in the Chinese city of Zibo proclaim it as the birthplace of football, to the fury of English experts.
A map in Zibo’s Qi State History Museum shows a thin line stretching from China to Egypt, then to Greece, Rome and France, before finishing in England, commonly known as the home of football after the rules were codified there in the 19th century.
The track represents the path of football’s development, according to the museum, with the certificate - signed by Blatter - honouring China as “the cradle of the earliest forms of football”.
But international experts are sceptical of such claims, pointing to a “tenuous” link between the ancient Chinese game of cuju and the modern sport, and questioning Fifa's motives.
Despite its long supposed footballing history China’s national team failed to qualify for the World Cup in Brazil later this month.
China has only appeared at one final tournament, in 2002, when they lost all three of their group matches and went out without even scoring a goal.
But millions of fans will be watching the tournament and in Zibo - the modern city on the site of the ancient Qi state’s capital Linzi - football is booming. Statues of cuju players stand on street corners and posters on bus shelters depict the supposed forebear of the modern game.
“I really like Sepp Blatter,” beams Zhu Shuju, vice director at the separate Zibo Football Museum, which pays homage to the sport’s history and gives huge prominence to Blatter and other Fifa officials.
“He is very popular here,” she added, surrounded by images of Blatter and with a video of his speech confirming Zibo’s status continuously looping in the background.
Zibo has invited Brazilian superstar Pele to open a new multi-million dollar museum later this year.
- ‘Absurd’ and ‘tenuous’ -
Different types of cuju existed in ancient China, but the competitive game still played today involves keeping a leather ball stuffed with feathers off the ground without using arms or hands, before heading or kicking it though a hole above head height.
A gladiatorial version with much physical contact emerged in the Warring States period which unified China almost 2,500 years ago, and was popular with soldiers exercising their legs after days on horseback. But experts outside China believe there are huge differences between cuju and modern football.
“I find it absurd to suggest ancient Chinese had comparable mentalities as football enthusiasts today,” Ellis Cashmore, professor of culture, media and sport at Britain’s Staffordshire University told AFP via email. “So the link is tenuous.”
Historians say other ball sports existed around the same time as cuju emerged, including a Greek game known as episkyros.
An ancient stone carving at the Acropolis Museum in Athens shows a naked Greek athlete balancing a ball on his thigh, and some say episkyros evolved into a game played by the Romans, called harpastum, which was then transported to Britain.
There the modern game was born when the Football Association rules, drawing on a public school mob game, were written by Ebenezer Cobb Morley in 1863, and have since changed very little.
For British historian Tom Holland, football began in the 19th century. “I’m afraid I don’t know anything about the classical origins of football, for the simple reason they don’t exist,” he said.
“Kicking something around is an obvious human activity,” he added.
“That various peoples, in various parts of the world, may or may not have engaged in such activities, does not prove that they were the originators of football.” British football author Jonathan Wilson agreed, saying that the 1863 rules “were then spread across the world by British sailors and traders”.
“At no point did they come upon a local form of football that needed to be eradicated before the British game could take root,” he said.
“Rather foreign cultures took on those laws and interpreted them in their own way.”
- ‘New territories’ -
Eyebrows were raised when Fifa came out in support of China’s claims.
“Blatter sees his brief to make football the richest sport in history and he has already achieved that,” said Cashmore, whose book “Football’s Dark Side” explores corruption in the game.
“But to maintain its commercial dominance, he needs to keep conquering new territories.
“China is obvious: huge territory, an economy that’s been growing like a blur and a population that has already shown enthusiasm for the sport.”
Fifa and Blatter have been criticised for several decisions in recent years, most vociferously over the controversial award of the 2022 World Cup to a tiny Gulf emirate that has immense gas wealth but sweltering summer temperatures.
British historian Guy Walters, from London’s New College of the Humanities, told AFP: “Frankly, I’m surprised he hasn’t stated that the game kicked off in the ancient deserts of Qatar.”